Guardianship and administration in Victoria
The general principles
Section 8(1) sets out three principles. Anyone exercising a power, function or duty under the Act must consider them. This includes VCAT, under s 8(2).
First, a person with a disability who needs support to make decisions should get practicable and appropriate support. This support helps them make and take part in decisions, and express their will and preferences. It should also help develop their decision-making capacity.
Second, as far as practicable, the person’s will and preferences should direct decisions made for them.
Third, powers, functions and duties should be exercised in the way least restrictive of the person’s ability to decide and act.
The first principle is unusual. It names building capacity as a goal, not just support leading to a decision.
The decision-making cascade
Section 9(1) is a Victorian provision. It sets up a cascade for making decisions for a represented person, meaning the steps must be followed in strict order.
First, the decision-maker must give effect to the person’s actual will and preferences, if these are known. Only if that is not possible does the decision-maker move to the next step.
Second, the decision-maker must work out what the person’s will and preferences are likely to be. This uses available information, including talking to relatives, close friends and carers.
Third, only if likely will and preferences cannot be worked out either, the decision-maker must act to promote the person’s personal and social wellbeing. Wellbeing is a last resort, not a starting point. Jumping straight to wellbeing, or to the person’s best interests, skips the earlier steps and misapplies the section.
Section 9(1)(d) is a further requirement. Where the represented person has a companion animal, the decision-maker must recognise the animal’s importance and any benefits it gives the person. Victoria’s legislation has this provision; New South Wales and South Australia do not.
Section 9(1)(e) sets a high bar for overriding the person’s will and preferences: this can only happen to prevent serious harm to them. Simply disagreeing with their decision, or a risk of harm that falls short of serious harm, is not enough to justify an override.
What VCAT may order
Under s 30(1), VCAT has four possible orders, plus a fifth option. It may make a guardianship order, an administration order, or a supportive order of either kind under s 87. It may also decide to make no order at all, under s 30(1)(b).
Supportive orders are a special feature of Victoria’s scheme. A supportive order helps a person make their own decisions, rather than letting someone else decide for them. This sits alongside the usual substitute decision-making orders, it does not replace them.
This is specific to Victoria. Students should not assume other states have the same option. The passage notes that neither New South Wales nor South Australia has an equivalent order in this form.
Three jurisdictions, three standards
Three states, three different legal tests. This matters because the differences are real, not just wording.
Victoria follows the person’s will and preferences first. Wellbeing only matters as a last resort, and decision-makers can only override preferences to stop serious harm.
New South Wales treats the person’s welfare and interests as paramount. The person’s views are considered, but they do not control the outcome.
South Australia asks what the person would have wanted if not mentally incapacitated. This is treated as paramount, separate from asking about their current wishes.
A student who learns only one test and applies it everywhere will get it wrong in two states out of three. This mistake is easy to miss if you do not already know the right answer.
Applying this in a problem question
In Victoria, first pin down the exact personal or financial matter in question. Test the person’s capacity against that specific matter under s 30(2)(a).
Next, check whether a supportive order under s 87 could solve the problem. Only move to a substitute order if a supportive order won’t work. Remember VCAT may decide to make no order at all.
Then apply the s 9 cascade in the correct order. Start with the person’s known will and preferences. If unknown, consider their likely will and preferences, found out through consultation. Only consider wellbeing last.
Do not start the analysis at wellbeing or at “best interests.” These come after considering will and preferences, not before.
If an override of the person’s wishes is proposed, apply s 9(1)(e). An override requires necessity to prevent serious harm.
Finally, where the facts involve a companion animal, address s 9(1)(d) specifically.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.