Guardianship and administration in Tasmania
The principles
Section 8(1) of Tasmania’s Act sets out seven principles. Anyone performing a function under the Act must follow them.
The first principle says a person’s decision-making ability must be respected and promoted. Promoting it means actively helping, not just leaving the person alone.
The second principle requires giving people the support they need to make decisions. This support should help them take part in decisions, express their will and preferences, and develop their decision-making ability over time.
The third principle deals with a person’s own views when their decision-making ability is impaired. Their views, wishes and preferences must be respected and used to inform decisions. This means their views guide the decision, but do not control it.
The other principles require recognising the role of close family, carers and other significant people. They also require preserving the person’s cultural and linguistic environment, promoting their personal and social well-being, and choosing the option least restrictive of their freedom.
Section 8(2) adds extra rules when the function relates to a child. As far as practicable, the child’s best interests must be treated as paramount.
What “in need of a guardian” requires
Section 20(2) tells the Tribunal, in Tasmania, what to consider when deciding if someone needs a guardian. First, it must consider the person’s wishes and preferences, as far as these can be worked out.
Second, it must ask whether less restrictive options could meet the person’s needs instead.
Because wishes come first in this list, the Tribunal must think about what the person wants before deciding need exists. An applicant should address this point directly.
The less-restrictive question is part of deciding need itself, not a separate rule. This differs from Western Australia, where s 4(4) works as a standalone bar stopping any order being made.
Applying this in a problem question
In Tasmania, use the Act’s term “impaired decision-making ability.” Assess it for the specific personal matters at issue.
Check all three parts of s 20(1) separately. Do not treat s 20(1)(c) as just a formality.
Under s 20(2), consider the person’s wishes and preferences when deciding if there is a need, not only as a separate principle. Also consider less restrictive options as part of that same need enquiry, as s 20(2)(b) requires.
When applying s 8(1)(c), say the person’s views inform the decision. Do not treat them as determining it.
Where support could help the person decide, apply s 8(1)(b) first. Only then consider whether substitution is needed.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.