Guardianship and administration in South Australia

The statutory gateway: mental incapacity

Section 3 (South Australia) defines mental incapacity as being unable to look after your own health, safety or welfare, or manage your affairs. This must result from one of two things.

The first is damage, illness, disorder, impaired development, or deterioration of the brain or mind.

The second is a physical illness or condition stopping a person communicating their wishes at all. This limb matters because it can apply even when thinking is unaffected, as long as communication is impossible.

The test asks whether a person can function — manage health, safety, welfare or affairs. It is not about diagnosis. A diagnosis alone does not prove or disprove incapacity.

What a guardian may do

In South Australia, s 31(1) gives a guardian all the powers a guardian has at law or equity. This is subject to the Act and to the terms of the guardian’s order.

Section 31(2) adds a specific power. If a protected person is an inpatient at an incorporated hospital, the guardian may decide they will live at a named aged care facility after discharge. The guardian may also authorise the person’s detention while moving them there, and detention at the facility itself.

This detention power deprives a person of their liberty. It is exercised by a guardian, who may be privately appointed, acting under a tribunal order. It should be treated as a distinct power, not just part of the general powers in s 31(1).

Section 31A works the other way. A guardian must take reasonable steps to find out if the person made an advance care directive. If one exists, the guardian must, so far as reasonably practicable, follow it.

Administration orders

Section 35(1) deals with administration orders for a person’s estate in South Australia. It works the same way as s 29.

SACAT must be satisfied the person has a mental incapacity. SACAT must also be satisfied an order should be made.

If both are satisfied, SACAT may appoint an administrator for part of the estate. This is called a limited administration order.

SACAT may instead appoint an administrator for the whole estate. This is a full administration order. SACAT can only do this if a limited order would not be appropriate.

The Public Trustee is one possible choice for administrator.

Applying this in a problem question

This is about South Australian guardianship problem questions. First, show mental incapacity under s 3, and state which of the two limbs applies.

Frame the question functionally. Focus on whether the person can look after their health, safety or welfare, or manage their affairs, not on their diagnosis.

Under s 5(a), apply substituted judgment, not best interests. Substituted judgment asks what the person themselves would have wanted, not what seems best for them.

Treat the person’s present wishes under s 5(b) separately from their hypothetical wishes under s 5(a). These are two different inquiries.

Before assuming an order is needed, check under s 5(c) whether informal arrangements are already adequate.

Argue for a limited order first. A full order under s 29 or s 35 needs an affirmative finding that a limited order would be inappropriate.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.