Guardianship and administration in Queensland
Structured decision-making: four steps
This is about Queensland. General principle 10 sets out four steps for applying general principle 9.
First, decision-makers must preserve the adult’s right to decide for themselves, as much as practicable. They should support the adult to make the decision if possible.
Second, they must consider the adult’s views, wishes and preferences. This includes preferences expressed or demonstrated, so conduct counts too.
Third, if those preferences cannot be worked out, the decision-maker considers what the preferences would be. This only applies where it is reasonably practicable to infer this from past views shown when the adult had capacity.
Fourth, only after considering steps one to three can the person actually make the decision. This step is a gate: the earlier steps are mandatory before acting.
The health care principles are separate
Section 11C(1) sets out separate rules called the health care principles. Anyone using a power under the Act for a health matter or special health matter must apply them.
Section 11C(2) extends this to other entities authorised under a different Act to decide about prescribed special health care. Section 11C(3) adjusts both sets of principles to fit that situation.
In Queensland, a decision-maker must apply the health care principles together with the general principles, not one instead of the other. Health care principle 1 confirms this: the general principles still apply alongside the health care principles.
Queensland’s approach in summary
Queensland starts with a presumption of capacity: adults are assumed able to decide for themselves.
It then uses a four-step approach. If the adult’s actual views can’t be found, decision-makers use their imputed views, wishes and preferences instead. Only after weighing these earlier steps can a decision be made at step four.
These principles bind both informal decision-makers and formally appointed ones.
Other states use different tests. Don’t apply another state’s approach to a Queensland case.
Applying this in a problem question
When answering a problem question, start with general principle 1: the presumption of capacity, meaning the law assumes someone can decide for themselves. Ask whether this presumption has been displaced for the specific matter in the facts.
Check whether the decision-maker is informal. Section 11B(2) still binds them even then.
Work through general principle 10 as a sequence of steps. Treat step four as a gate, not merely a summary of what came before.
At step two, look for preferences shown through conduct, not only words.
For a health matter, apply the health care principles in s 11C alongside the general principles. Health care principle 1 expressly requires this.
For an appointment, address all three elements of s 12(1) separately, keeping each one matter-specific.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.