Guardianship and enduring guardianship in New South Wales

The general principles, and how they differ from South Australia

Section 4 of the (NSW) Act sets out eight principles. Everyone exercising functions under the Act must follow them.

The first principle is that a person’s welfare and interests must be given paramount consideration. This means it is the top priority above the other principles.

The other principles say: restrict a person’s freedom as little as possible; help them live a normal life in the community; take their views into account; preserve family, cultural and language ties; encourage self-reliance in personal and financial matters; protect them from neglect, abuse and exploitation; and encourage the community to support these principles.

Jurisdiction matters here. New South Wales makes welfare and interests paramount, and only requires the person’s views to be considered, not followed.

South Australia’s Guardianship and Administration Act 1993 is different. It makes paramount what the person would have wanted, if not for their incapacity.

So the two Acts prioritise different things. Using the NSW test in a South Australian problem, or vice versa, gives the wrong answer.

Guardianship orders under Part 3

Section 14 lets the Tribunal (in New South Wales) make a guardianship order, but only after a hearing and only if satisfied the person needs a guardian.

Before deciding, it must consider several things. These include the person’s own views, the views of a spouse in a close ongoing relationship, and the views of their carer. It must also weigh the importance of keeping family relationships and cultural and linguistic ties intact.

Finally, it must consider whether services could be provided without an order at all. This checks whether informal arrangements already make an order unnecessary.

Section 15 then limits the Tribunal’s power in four ways. No order can be made for a person under 16. No order can be made where the person is already under a Supreme Court guardianship order, or a Children’s Court order under s 79A of the Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998, unless that court consents.

Three of the remaining limits are “least-restrictive” rules. A temporary order cannot be made if it is practicable to make a continuing order instead, appointing someone other than the Public Guardian.

Similarly, a continuing order cannot appoint the Public Guardian if some other suitable person could be appointed instead (s 15(3)). This rule is worth remembering by its number, since it comes up often.

Last, a plenary guardianship order (one giving broad, open-ended powers) cannot be made if a limited guardianship order would be enough (s 15(4)).

What the order must contain

This section applies to New South Wales guardianship orders. Section 16(1) says an order must appoint a guardian aged 18 or over. It must state whether the order is continuing or temporary, and plenary (full) or limited. Conditions may also be attached.

Under s 16(2), a limited order must specify any custody the guardian has, and which specific functions the guardian may perform.

Section 16(3) allows two or more guardians under one or more limited orders. They may act jointly with the same functions, or separately with different functions. The Public Guardian cannot be appointed as a joint guardian.

Section 8 keeps the Supreme Court’s own guardianship powers. This Part does not limit that separate jurisdiction.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.