Tendency and coincidence evidence

Tendency evidence

Tendency evidence shows a person tends to act a certain way, or hold a certain state of mind. It is used to argue they acted or thought the same way on the occasion in question.

Hughes v The Queen confirms this evidence is only admissible if it has significant probative value, as the legislation requires. Typical examples are past conduct showing a disposition, or a settled attitude showing the person held it at the relevant time. The reasoning is inferential: past behaviour or disposition makes it more likely the person acted consistently this time.

In New South Wales, one category of case works differently. Section 97A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) applies where a child sexual offence is in issue. It presumes that tendency evidence about the defendant’s sexual interest in children has significant probative value, even if the defendant never acted on that interest. This applies whether or not the interest was directed at the complainant.

A court may still decide the evidence lacks significant probative value, if there are sufficient grounds. But s 97A(5) excludes seven matters from that assessment, unless exceptional circumstances apply — including that the tendency act differs from the act alleged. Students should check whether s 97A applies before using the ordinary test.

Coincidence evidence

Coincidence evidence works differently. It shows that two or more events happened. It is used to argue these events are unlikely to be mere coincidence.

The point is to prove a person did something, or had a certain state of mind. The reasoning relies on shared features linking the events. It asks the fact-finder to infer a fact because the pattern is too unlikely to be chance.

Tendency and coincidence evidence often appear in the same case, based on similar facts. The same evidence can sometimes support both arguments. But they use different reasoning, and each remains a separate rule with its own conditions.

Why both are treated with caution

Both rules guard against prejudicial propensity reasoning. This means a fact-finder hears about a person’s bad past conduct, then wrongly assumes they are “the type” to have done the act charged. The danger is convicting someone based on character, not on evidence they actually did this specific thing.

This reasoning feels convincing but is logically weak. It is especially unfair to an accused, whose past can wrongly become the trial’s real focus.

Because of this risk, tendency and coincidence evidence face a heightened admissibility threshold. It is not enough that the evidence is merely relevant; it generally needs materially higher probative value before courts admit it.

When the prosecution uses this evidence against an accused, courts balance probative value against unfair prejudice more strictly. Under s 101(2) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), such evidence cannot be used against a defendant unless its probative value substantially outweighs any prejudicial effect.

The exact threshold and accompanying safeguards, like notice requirements, vary between the uniform evidence law and other jurisdictions. Still, this underlying caution remains consistent across Australian evidence law.

Working through a tendency or coincidence problem

Start by pinpointing exactly what the evidence is meant to prove. Ask whether that inference rests on disposition (tendency) or on the improbability of coincidence (coincidence). Only then check if the heightened threshold for admitting it is met.

Don’t assume this evidence is automatically inadmissible. If its probative value is genuinely high — say, a distinctive and unusual feature linking separate events — the threshold can still be satisfied.

On identity evidence, Hughes is narrower than it first appears. In TL v The King (2022) 275 CLR 83, the Court explained that Hughes’s “close similarity” requirement applies mainly where there is little other evidence of identity, and the perpetrator’s identity is genuinely “at large”.

Where other identification evidence is strong, the Court held the threshold can be met without that close similarity.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by asking what the evidence is meant to show. Tendency evidence suggests a disposition, a pattern in someone’s character or conduct. Coincidence evidence suggests events are too similar to have happened by chance. Some evidence can serve both purposes.

Next, trace the exact reasoning from the evidence to the fact it is meant to prove. Check its genuine probative value, meaning how strongly it actually helps prove that fact, based on the specific facts of the problem.

Remember this evidence faces a heightened admissibility threshold, not just ordinary relevance. Weigh its probative value against the risk of unfair prejudice especially carefully.

Think about whether the evidence might invite prejudicial propensity reasoning. This means the jury wrongly assumes guilt from bad character, rather than using the evidence properly. Consider whether this risk can be managed.

Finally, identify which jurisdiction applies. The admissibility threshold and any notice requirements differ between the uniform evidence law and Queensland, South Australia, and Western Australia.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.