Settlement negotiations and exceptions to protection
The statutory threshold
Several Australian Evidence Acts share this rule in section 131(1): the Commonwealth, NSW, Victoria, Tasmania, ACT and NT versions. The rule protects communications between disputing parties, or with a third party, made to try to settle the dispute. It also protects documents prepared for that purpose, even if never sent.
The dispute must be one where a court (in Australia or overseas) could give relief. The rule does not apply to settling criminal or anticipated criminal charges. Plea negotiations are not covered just because people might loosely call them a “settlement”. The rule also covers communications by an authorised employee or agent, including giving consent.
Whether the rule applies depends on the communication’s connection to settlement efforts. Adding a “without prejudice” heading does not automatically protect a plain demand for payment. Equally, leaving off that heading does not automatically remove protection either.
You need to identify the dispute, who was involved, and the purpose of the specific communication. An unsent draft can still count as a protected document. But an old, unrelated document does not become protected just because someone later puts it in a settlement file.
Consent, openness and partial disclosure
Section 131(2)(a)–(d) covers consent, disclosure and non-confidential statements. If everyone in dispute consents, the evidence can be used. If one party has already tendered the communication in another proceeding, the others must all consent too.
Another exception applies where everyone has expressly or impliedly consented to disclosing the substance of the communication. But one negotiator wanting to reveal a helpful concession is not the same as proper consent from all parties.
Where parties agreed to partial disclosure, paragraph (c) only applies if full disclosure is reasonably necessary to properly understand evidence already given. This is not a general excuse to tender the whole negotiation just because part of it is already known.
Paragraph (d) applies separately, where the communication itself says it is not confidential. The student should check what was actually said, not assume every message included this statement.
Paragraph (e) allows evidence that contradicts or qualifies evidence already admitted about settlement attempts. Paragraph (g) applies where admitted evidence (or an inference from it) might mislead the court, unless the negotiation material corrects this.
Both exceptions require a real connection to evidence already before the court. Simply arguing “fairness” is not enough without pointing to this statutory link.
Trial evidence and compelled disclosure
The six section 131 provisions are mostly alike. One difference: ACT uses “presented” where other Acts say “adduced”.
NSW, Victoria, Tasmania, ACT and NT also have section 131A. This extends the same public-interest exclusions to certain court disclosure demands, like subpoenas, discovery and interrogatories, if the person objects. Victoria alone also covers search warrants, under section 131A(2)(g).
Commonwealth section 131A is different. It extends journalist privilege, not section 131. So it cannot be used to protect settlement material from disclosure under Commonwealth law; other rules apply there instead.
Even where a section 131 exception applies, this does not guarantee the evidence gets admitted. Relevance, hearsay, other privileges and specialist legislation are still separate hurdles.
NSW also has a specific override. Under the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), section 7D(4), section 131(1) cannot block settlement-negotiation evidence in proceedings to set aside an affected child-abuse settlement agreement under section 7D. Sections 7B–7C define which agreements qualify; this is not a general exception for all settlement challenges. The override only removes the section 131(1) obstacle — it does not decide whether the agreement should be set aside.
Worked application
Here’s an example from a NSW debt dispute. A supplier offers to accept half the invoice to avoid trial. The buyer wants to use that email to show the supplier admits the full invoice was unjustified. This fails: an offer to compromise does not, by itself, admit liability under section 131.
Change the purpose, though. If the parties dispute whether accepting the email actually formed a settlement, paragraph (f) may allow the evidence, because the existence of the agreement is itself in issue.
If the supplier later relies on the email regarding costs, paragraph (h) may apply instead.
If the email is subpoenaed before trial, the recipient should raise section 131A and object on disclosure grounds. Do not assume an evidentiary exclusion automatically defeats a subpoena.
So the same email needs fresh analysis at each separate stage.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by finding the Evidence Act that applies. Work out the dispute, the material in question, and how it connects to a settlement negotiation.
Check the statutory definition carefully. This includes the exclusion for criminal negotiations, plus any agency or consent requirements that apply.
Match the use you propose to a specific exception. Explain each condition fully. Do not rely on a vague fairness exception that isn’t defined.
Keep three things separate: proving liability, enforcing a settlement, and costs. Don’t mix up the substantive rules with the costs rules.
If someone demands disclosure, identify the correct local procedure first. Then work out what section 131A actually covers, before turning to any other objections to admissibility.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.