Relevance
The test for relevance
Evidence is relevant if it could rationally affect, directly or indirectly, the probability of a fact in issue. This is the test in s 55 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) and its uniform counterparts, applied in Smith v The Queen (2001) 206 CLR 650.
The evidence does not need to be convincing or decisive. It only needs to be capable of rationally making a fact in issue more or less probable.
Direct relevance means the evidence itself is or describes the fact in issue, like an eyewitness account. Indirect (circumstantial) relevance means the evidence supports another fact, which then supports the fact in issue. This extra step is allowed, but it must be rational, not speculative.
Facts in issue come from the pleadings in civil cases, or the charge and defences in criminal cases. Evidence about something neither party has raised is not relevant, no matter how interesting.
However, evidence is not irrelevant merely because it only affects a witness’s credibility, the admissibility of other evidence, or explains a failure to produce evidence (s 55(2)).
Relevance is assessed for each piece of evidence, but often only makes sense alongside the rest of the case. Something trivial alone may become relevant through its connection to other evidence.
Necessary, not sufficient
Passing the relevance test is only the first step. It does not mean the evidence will be let in.
Relevant evidence can still be excluded under rules on hearsay, opinion, tendency and coincidence reasoning, and privilege. These are explained in other articles.
Under the uniform evidence law, two more provisions can exclude relevant evidence. Section 135 says a court may refuse evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice, confusion, or wasted time. Section 137 says a court must refuse prosecution evidence in a criminal case if its probative value is outweighed by unfair prejudice to the defendant.
The key point is the order. Relevance is decided first. Only then do these other rules apply.
Irrelevant evidence cannot be saved by any other rule. No exception, no witness expertise, and no absence of prejudice can make it admissible. Irrelevance is a complete bar.
The jurisdictional split students must hold in mind
Australia has no single national law of evidence. Many jurisdictions share a common statutory template, called the uniform evidence law. This includes the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory.
Queensland and South Australia have not adopted this uniform scheme. Western Australia has enacted it but not yet commenced most of it. Only Part 1 and s 384 of the Evidence Act 2025 (WA) operate now; the rest starts on 18 September 2027.
These three jurisdictions keep their own evidence law instead. It rests mainly on common law, plus their own separate Evidence Acts. These differ from the uniform scheme in structure and in the detail of specific rules.
This split affects real substance, not just labels. The wording of the relevance test, the structure of exclusionary rules, and which exceptions apply can all differ between uniform and non-uniform jurisdictions.
The court matters too, not just the location. The Commonwealth Act applies in every federal court proceeding, even one sitting in a state that hasn’t adopted the uniform scheme.
This module states general principles that hold conceptually across Australian evidence law. But in a problem question, always identify the relevant jurisdiction first. Check whether the uniform scheme or a non-uniform state’s law applies before stating the detail of any rule.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the fact in issue — the fact the evidence is meant to prove. Draw it from the pleadings or the charge.
Then ask whether the evidence could rationally affect the probability of that fact. This can be direct, or indirect through a further logical step.
If it fails this test, stop. The evidence is inadmissible, and no other rule can rescue it.
If it passes, this doesn’t mean the evidence is admissible. You still must check the exclusionary rules and discretionary exclusion.
Finally, identify the jurisdiction. Note whether it’s a uniform evidence law jurisdiction, or Queensland, South Australia or Western Australia, before relying on any specific admissibility rule’s detail.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.