Real evidence: views, demonstrations and experiments

The Act does not close off other routes

Section 52 says the Act (apart from Part 2.3) does not stop other Australian laws or practices allowing evidence in ways other than witnesses or documents.

This is a saving provision. It just confirms that other routes for adducing evidence survive the Act.

But this does not mean everything outside witnesses and documents falls under s 53. Section 53 only covers three things: a demonstration, an experiment, or an inspection ordered by the judge.

So after s 52, the real question is whether what’s proposed fits one of those three categories. Other things, like what an expert does to form an opinion, or a recording tendered as a document, are governed by different provisions entirely.

Section 53: the order, and the two preconditions

Section 53 lets a judge order a demonstration, experiment or inspection, but only if a party applies for it. The court cannot do this on its own. The three terms differ: a demonstration shows how something was done, an experiment tests if something could happen, and an inspection views a place or thing.

Before making the order, the judge must be satisfied of two things: that the parties will get a reasonable chance to be present, and that the judge (and any jury) will be present. These are preconditions, not mere factors. An order made without both is made without power.

Tasmania is different. Under section 53(2)(b) of its Evidence Act, only the jury’s presence is required, not the judge’s. The Tasmanian Act itself notes this divergence from the Commonwealth provision.

Two limits that catch people out

Two rules trip people up here.

Section 53(4) says juries cannot run experiments during deliberations. Testing a signature or trying a key in a lock would break this rule. But s 53(5) says this ban does not cover inspecting an exhibit, so the hard part is telling an experiment from an inspection on the facts.

If the jury does run a forbidden experiment, the section itself does not say what happens next. That depends on how serious the irregularity was, and whether it affected the verdict.

Section 53(5) also means an exhibit already in evidence can simply be examined, without needing a court order. This is why a jury handling a weapon in the jury room differs from a jury visiting a crime scene.

Section 54: what the court may do with what it saw

Section 54 lets the court, including the jury, draw reasonable inferences. This applies to what they see, hear or notice during a demonstration, experiment or inspection.

This confirms that a view is itself evidence. It is not just a tool to help understand other evidence.

So saying a view only helps the jury follow testimony is wrong. It understates what the view actually is.

A worked application

Here the plaintiff tripped on an uneven footpath at dusk. She wants a view (an inspection of the site) and a demonstration of the gait the surface caused.

The footpath was resurfaced eight months ago. This engages s 53(3)(e): the place has materially changed. That factor weighs against ordering a view, but doesn’t rule it out — the judge may still find the surrounding layout useful.

The dusk timing raises s 53(3)(b): will inspecting actually help the court? An inspection done at midday, of something that happened at dusk, risks being misleading — that’s s 53(3)(c).

The demonstration raises s 53(3)(d): will it properly reproduce what’s in dispute? Doing it on a different surface, with the plaintiff now alert to the hazard, reproduces very little. The real argument is identifying which features are missing, not just calling it unreliable.

Two preconditions must be met regardless of how those factors come out: the parties must get a reasonable chance to be present, and — under the Commonwealth, NSW, Victorian, ACT or NT Acts — the judge and any jury must be present too.

If the same case were in Tasmania, the judge would still need to be satisfied the parties get a reasonable opportunity to attend, and that any jury is present. Tasmania only drops the requirement that the judge personally be present — not the parties’ opportunity to attend.

Finally, if the order is made, s 54 means whatever the tribunal observes becomes evidence it can use in its reasoning.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by asking how the evidence is being adduced: testimony, document, or otherwise. Section 52 confirms this third route still exists, but does not say s 53 governs it.

Next, check if it is actually one of the three s 53 procedures: a demonstration, an experiment, or an inspection ordered on application. Name which one it is, since each attracts different factors. A recording tendered as evidence, or something an expert did to form an opinion, belongs elsewhere in the Act.

Before discussing discretion, check the two preconditions in s 53(2). Use the exact words of the governing Act. Note that in Tasmania, the second precondition only requires that any jury will be present.

Then apply whichever s 53(3) factors suit the procedure. Proper reproduction matters most for a demonstration; material alteration matters most for an inspection.

Consider s 53(4) if the jury is said to have tested something itself. Consider s 53(5) if what occurred was inspection of an exhibit, rather than a view.

Finally, apply s 54 to work out what the tribunal may draw from the evidence.

Where the authority sits

This kind of real evidence sits under Part 2.3 of the uniform Acts. Section 52 keeps other ways of adducing evidence available.

Sections 52, 54 and most of s 53 work the same way across the Commonwealth, NSW, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory. Wording differs slightly between jurisdictions, but the legal effect does not.

Subsection 53(2) is different in substance: Tasmania does not require the judge to be present for this kind of evidence. Always check which court you are dealing with before applying the test.

Queensland, Western Australia and South Australia do not use these uniform provisions. Queensland and South Australia have not adopted the scheme at all; views and demonstrations there follow their own State law.

Western Australia has adopted the scheme, in its Evidence Act 2025 (WA), but under different numbering: s 63 matches Commonwealth s 52, s 64 matches s 53, and s 65 matches s 54. WA’s s 64(2) follows the Commonwealth approach, requiring the judge’s presence, not the Tasmanian exception.

However, these WA provisions are in Part 2, which has not yet commenced. Only Part 1 and s 384 currently operate. The rest, including Part 2, commences on 18 September 2027.

So until then, a Western Australian court applies that State’s existing evidence law, not these provisions.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.