Privilege
Client legal privilege
Client legal privilege (also called legal professional privilege) protects private communications between a lawyer and client. It also protects confidential documents. These must be made for the dominant purpose of giving legal advice, or for actual or contemplated litigation.
The dominant purpose test is key. It was confirmed in Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1999). If a communication has several purposes, it is only privileged if the legal or litigation purpose was the main, most influential one. A document made mainly for commercial reasons stays unprivileged, even if a lawyer was briefly involved.
The communication must also stay confidential. Sharing it with outsiders, or making it public, will usually destroy the privilege.
Privilege belongs to the client, not the lawyer. The client can waive it, either expressly or through conduct — for example, by disclosing the advice to someone else, or relying on it in court.
Why the privilege exists
Privilege exists for a practical reason, not because the evidence is unreliable. It encourages clients to be fully honest with their lawyers.
If clients feared their words could be used against them in court, they would hold back. This would stop lawyers giving good advice and representing clients properly.
The law accepts that this sometimes excludes relevant, reliable evidence. It decides the benefit of open client-lawyer communication outweighs this loss in individual cases.
This explains why privilege can block even highly trustworthy evidence. Unlike hearsay or opinion evidence, privilege has nothing to do with doubts about reliability.
Other recognised privileges
Client legal privilege gets the most attention, but other privileges exist too.
The privilege against self-incrimination lets a person refuse to answer questions or give documents. This applies where doing so risks exposing them to prosecution or penalty. The idea is that legal process should not force someone to help convict themselves.
This privilege is not guaranteed in every case. Some statutes change or remove it in specific contexts. Always check the particular proceeding before assuming it applies.
Without-prejudice privilege, also called settlement privilege, protects genuine settlement negotiations. Communications made in a bona fide attempt to settle a dispute cannot later be used as admissions in court.
This exists for similar reasons as client legal privilege. Parties negotiate more openly, and settle disputes more easily, if their negotiation statements cannot be used against them later if talks fail.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the communication or document claimed to be privileged. Note who created it, and who it was made for.
For client legal privilege, check two things: was it confidential, and was it made for the dominant purpose of legal advice or litigation (actual or contemplated)?
Next, check if confidentiality was lost, or the privilege waived. This can happen through disclosure to a third party, or through conduct by the client that is inconsistent with keeping it private.
If client legal privilege does not fit, consider other types instead. Self-incrimination privilege or without-prejudice privilege may apply more clearly.
Finally, remember privilege applies regardless of how relevant or reliable the evidence is. Do not argue against privilege just by pointing to the evidence’s probative value.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.