Opinion evidence
The general rule
The opinion rule says opinion evidence is generally not admissible to prove a fact. An opinion is an inference or conclusion drawn from facts, not a direct account of them.
The concern is that drawing inferences is the fact-finder’s job. If a witness just states a conclusion, the fact-finder cannot test the reasoning behind it.
So witnesses are expected to describe what they actually observed, leaving inferences to the fact-finder. But this line is not always sharp, since everyday language often blends observation and inference. That is why exceptions to the rule matter in practice.
The expert opinion exception
The biggest exception to the opinion rule is expert opinion evidence. Someone with specialised knowledge, gained through training, study or experience, can give an opinion based on that knowledge.
This only works if the opinion falls within the expert’s actual field. It must also help the fact-finder understand something outside ordinary lay experience. Clark v Ryan requires this specialised knowledge to be real, not just claimed.
The idea is this: some subjects genuinely need expert understanding, whether technical, scientific or medical. Hearing a qualified opinion helps the fact-finder rather than taking over their job. But the expert must explain their reasoning and basis, so it can be tested rather than just accepted.
At common law, part of this requirement is now uncertain. In Lang v The Queen, two judges (Kiefel CJ and Gageler J) said the traditional approach is under strain. They suggested expert opinion isn’t automatically excluded just because a jury could reason it out using ordinary knowledge instead.
These two judges said what still matters is this: the opinion must be based on specialised knowledge beyond ordinary knowledge. But this was only the view of two judges, not the whole Court. Jagot J used the older Clark v Ryan test without this change, and two judges dissented entirely.
In jurisdictions using the uniform Evidence Act, these rules come from statute. Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar says s 79(1) sets two requirements. First, the witness needs specialised knowledge from training, study or experience. Second, the opinion must be wholly or substantially based on that knowledge.
To rely on this exception, you generally must show three things. The witness has the right specialised knowledge. The opinion genuinely comes from that knowledge, not speculation or advocacy. And the opinion stays within the expert’s actual area of expertise.
Lay opinion evidence
Lay opinion evidence is an opinion given by an ordinary witness, not an expert. The law allows this only in limited situations.
It usually applies when the opinion is about something within ordinary human experience. It must also be necessary to explain what the witness actually perceived.
Common examples: saying someone seemed drunk, a car was going fast, or a person looked upset. These sound like conclusions, but they sum up many small observations. Breaking them into pure sensory detail would be awkward.
This exception is narrow. It does not cover opinions on complex or technical matters.
Under the uniform Evidence Acts, an opinion is not automatically inadmissible just because it touches the exact issue the court must decide (s80). So a lay opinion on that ultimate issue isn’t excluded for that reason alone. It must still satisfy the other conditions of the lay opinion exception.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out if the testimony is a direct account of what was perceived, or a conclusion drawn from it. The opinion rule only applies to the second kind.
If it is opinion, check whether the witness has specialised knowledge from training, study or experience. The opinion must genuinely come from, and stay within, that knowledge.
If the witness isn’t an expert, consider the lay opinion exception. This covers ordinary matters within common experience, expressed naturally to convey what was perceived.
Watch for opinions that touch the ultimate issue — the very question the fact-finder must decide. These need closer scrutiny, even from generally qualified witnesses.
Finally, remember the opinion rule is just one hurdle. The evidence must still be relevant and clear any other exclusionary rule that applies.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.