Hearsay

What the rule excludes

The hearsay rule is in s 59 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). It generally stops a previous representation being used as evidence. A previous representation is any statement, made in words, writing, or conduct, in or out of court.

The rule only applies when the statement is tendered to prove that what it says is true. This is called tendering it for a hearsay purpose.

The same statement can be used for a different purpose. For example, to show it was simply made, or its effect on someone who heard it. Used this way, the hearsay rule does not apply.

A statement does not need to be made in court to cause a hearsay problem. A document, a secondhand account from a witness, or conduct implying something, can all count. This applies whenever they are used to prove the truth of what they assert.

Why the rule exists

The hearsay rule exists because we cannot test the maker of a statement. Normally a fact-finder checks reliability through oath, presence, and cross-examination (questioning a witness to test their evidence). These safeguards were missing when the original statement was made.

This means the opposing party cannot test the maker’s perception, memory, honesty, or wording at the time. If the maker is never called, there is no way to test them at all.

This concern explains the rule, but does not limit it. The rule still applies even if the maker later gives evidence.

The Act’s own example: a statement that a car’s handbrake did not work cannot be proved by the maker, the hearer, or anyone else, unless an exception applies.

A “previous representation” means a statement made outside the court proceeding where it is now being used. So even if someone was cross-examined about it in an earlier proceeding, it still counts as a previous representation now.

Whether such a statement can be admitted still depends on whether an exception applies.

Exceptions exist, and matter

If hearsay were an absolute rule, courts would have to exclude evidence they normally rely on. This includes business records, admissions, and reliable statements. So the law allows many exceptions to the hearsay rule.

Both the uniform evidence law and the non-uniform states have these exceptions. They apply to previous representations seen as reliable, or necessary because the original maker is unavailable.

This module does not list every exception. The exceptions differ between jurisdictions, and working through them needs more detail than an orienting article allows.

The key lesson is structural. Do not assume a previous representation is excluded just because it is hearsay.

Instead, first check that the hearsay rule applies. Then ask whether a recognised exception applies to the facts, under the relevant jurisdiction’s law.

Working through a hearsay problem

A common mistake is skipping the question: was the statement tendered to prove the truth of what it asserts?

If a statement is only used to show that words were spoken, it is not hearsay. For example, proving a warning was given does not depend on whether the warning was true.

Telling this non-hearsay use apart from a hearsay use of the same words is often the key issue. You must work this out before considering any exception.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by finding the previous representation. This is the earlier words, writing or conduct made outside this proceeding’s evidence, usually but not always out of court.

Next ask why it’s being used. If it’s tendered to prove the representation is true, the hearsay rule applies. If it’s only tendered to show something was said, or how it affected a listener, the rule does not apply.

If the rule does apply, the evidence isn’t automatically excluded. Check whether a recognised exception fits the facts.

Identify which jurisdiction’s law applies, since exceptions differ between the uniform evidence law and Queensland, South Australia and Western Australia.

Finally, link your answer back to the reason for the rule: could the original speaker be cross-examined? If not, ask whether an exception still justifies letting the evidence in.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.