Client legal privilege under the uniform Acts: advice, litigation and loss

Client legal privilege as the uniform Acts state it: advice privilege under s 118, litigation privilege under s 119, the shared dominant purpose test, and how privilege is lost under ss 122 and 125.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, tas, act, nt
Subjects
evidence
Topics
privilege

Learning outcomes

  • Distinguish advice privilege under s 118 from litigation privilege under s 119 by the dominant purpose, not the counterparty.
  • Apply the dominant purpose test to the making of the communication rather than to its later use.
  • Identify when privilege is lost by consent or by conduct inconsistent with objecting under s 122.
  • Apply s 125 to its specific categories — fraud, an offence, an act attracting a civil penalty, or deliberate abuse of a statutory power.
  • State what s 131A does in New South Wales, and the conditions and exclusions it carries.

Client legal privilege is usually met as a rationale — that people should be able to consult a lawyer frankly — and that rationale decides nothing in a problem question. Under the uniform evidence legislation the privilege is statutory, it is framed around objection by the client rather than around a general immunity, and the question that decides most disputes is not whether privilege ever attached but whether it has been lost.

This article states the position under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Sections 118, 119, 122 and 125 are enacted to the same effect, under the same numbers, in New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory; the differences between the texts are drafting ones, and the ACT Act says “presenting” where the others say “adducing”.5 The scheme also reaches past the adducing of evidence: each of the five State and Territory Acts carries a s 131A for an objection to a court’s disclosure requirement, and the New South Wales section is set out below.6 For the rationale and the common law background, see Privilege.

The statutory frame: objection, and adducing evidence

Sections 118 and 119 are both expressed the same way: evidence is not to be adduced if, on objection by a client, the court finds that adducing it would result in a disclosure of the described kind.1

Two things follow that students routinely skip. The privilege operates on objection — it is a protection the client invokes, not a bar the court applies of its own motion. And Part 3.10 Division 1 is about adducing evidence in a proceeding.

The State and Territory Acts go further on that second point, on conditions. Section 131A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), “Application of Part to preliminary proceedings of courts”, does not simply apply the Part to document requests at large. It operates where a person is required by a disclosure requirement to give information or produce a document that would disclose material of a kind referred to in Division 1, 1A, 1C or 3 of the Part, and the person objects. The court must then determine the objection by applying the provisions of the Part, other than ss 123 and 128, with any necessary modifications, as if the objection were an objection to the giving or adducing of evidence. “Disclosure requirement” is defined, and the definition is what makes the section useful: it covers a summons or subpoena to produce documents or give evidence, pre-trial discovery, non-party discovery, interrogatories, a notice to produce, and a request to produce a document under Division 1 of Part 4.6. So in New South Wales the privilege can be raised against a subpoena — by that route, on objection, and with those two sections left out of the provisions applied.6

The other State and Territory Acts carry the same section, and it is the Commonwealth Act that is the odd one out. Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory each have a s 131A to the same effect; what differs is what each one catches. The Divisions listed in subsection (1)(a) vary — New South Wales Divisions 1, 1A, 1C or 3; Victoria 1, 1C or 3; Tasmania 1, 1A or 3 together with ss 127A and 127B; the ACT divs 3.10.1, 3.10.1A, 3.10.1C and 3.10.3; the Northern Territory 1, 1A or 3 — and the Victorian definition of “disclosure requirement” includes a search warrant, which the New South Wales definition does not.5 Do not read across from the Commonwealth Act here: its s 131A is a different provision altogether, extending Division 1C, journalist privilege, and no part of Division 1.5

Advice privilege: s 118

Section 118 protects a confidential communication between the client and a lawyer, a confidential communication between two or more lawyers acting for the client, or the contents of a confidential document prepared by the client, lawyer or another person — in each case made or prepared for the dominant purpose of the lawyer providing legal advice to the client.1

Note what is protected and what is not. The communication must be confidential; the document need not have been delivered; and the dominant purpose must be legal advice, not commercial advice that a lawyer happens to give.

Litigation privilege: s 119

Section 119 reaches a wider range of participants, but it is not a larger class that contains s 118. It protects a confidential communication between the client and another person, or between a lawyer acting for the client and another person, or the contents of a confidential document, prepared for the dominant purpose of the client being provided with professional legal services relating to an Australian or overseas proceeding — including an anticipated or pending proceeding — in which the client is or may be, or was or might have been, a party.2

The difference from s 118 is the PURPOSE, not the counterparty. Section 118 asks whether the dominant purpose was legal advice; s 119 asks whether it was professional legal services relating to a proceeding. Third-party involvement is not a requirement — s 119(b) protects a confidential document whatever the counterparty — but s 119(a) does expressly reach a communication between the client, or a lawyer acting for the client, and another person, which is why expert reports and witness proofs are usually argued under s 119 rather than s 118.

Neither section contains the other. Section 119 requires a proceeding — actual, anticipated or pending — so a communication whose dominant purpose was legal advice with no proceeding in contemplation can satisfy s 118 and fall outside s 119 altogether. Decide which section is in play from the dominant purpose, and do not treat a failure under one as a failure under both.

The dominant purpose test is shared, and it is not “a purpose”

Both sections turn on dominant purpose. A communication made for two purposes of roughly equal weight does not satisfy it. This is where most privilege claims are won or lost, and it is a question about the purpose for which the communication was made or the document prepared, not about how it was later used.

Loss of privilege, which is where the marks are

Privilege attaches where the requirements of s 118 or s 119 are made out — a confidential communication or document, and the relevant dominant purpose — and it may then be lost. Several provisions do that work. Two carry most of it.

Consent and inconsistency — s 122. The Division does not prevent evidence being adduced with the client’s consent; and, subject to s 122(5), it does not prevent it where the client has acted in a way that is inconsistent with objecting. Section 122(3) deems that to include knowingly and voluntarily disclosing the substance of the evidence to another person, or the substance being disclosed with the client’s express or implied consent.3

The statutory question is whether the conduct is inconsistent with maintaining the objection. Two carve-outs stop that being read too widely: s 122(4) takes an unauthorised disclosure by an employee or agent out of the deemed disclosure in s 122(3)(a) — it does not stop such a disclosure being inconsistent conduct under s 122(2). And s 122(5) provides that disclosure is not inconsistency merely because it was made in a confidential communication or document, or resulted from duress or deception, among other cases. So an answer that stops at “the document was disclosed” has not finished.

Misconduct — s 125. The Division does not prevent evidence of a communication made or document prepared by the client, the lawyer, or an unrepresented party in furtherance of the commission of a fraud, an offence, or an act rendering a person liable to a civil penalty; or of a communication or document that the client, lawyer or party knew or ought reasonably to have known was made in furtherance of a deliberate abuse of a power — s 125(3) defining power as one conferred by or under an Australian law.4 The categories are specific; misconduct at large is not the test.

The phrase is in furtherance of, and it carries the section. A later finding that the conduct was unlawful does not by itself show that the communication furthered it — and advice may itself further the misconduct, so the opposite inference is not safe either. Ask what the communication did, not what was later found.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the communication or document, and who the parties to it were.
  2. Ask whether it is confidential, then ask what the dominant purpose was: legal advice (s 118) or professional legal services relating to a proceeding (s 119). Do not decide it on the counterparty.
  3. For s 119, establish the proceeding — actual, anticipated or pending.
  4. State the dominant purpose and test it against the facts, rather than asserting it.
  5. Then ask what has happened since: consent or conduct inconsistent with objecting (s 122), or whether the communication itself furthered a fraud, an offence, an act attracting a civil penalty, or a deliberate abuse of a statutory power (s 125).
  6. Remember the privilege operates on the client’s objection, and that the Division governs the adducing of evidence — though in each of the five State and Territory Acts s 131A also carries it into an objection to a court’s disclosure requirement, on the conditions that section imposes.

Self-check

  • Can I say which of ss 118 and 119 applies from the purpose, rather than from who the counterparty was?
  • Have I tested dominant purpose rather than finding a legal purpose?
  • Have I asked whether privilege was lost before concluding that it protects the document?
  • Do I know what s 122 actually asks — inconsistency, not fairness?
  • Do I know what s 131A does, and the three things it requires before the Part applies to a subpoena?

Where the authority sits

The test is statutory — in the Commonwealth Act, Part 3.10 Division 1 — with the loss provisions in ss 121 to 126. Sections 118, 119, 122 and 125 are enacted to the same effect in the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory, so the position stated above holds in all six. Each of the five State and Territory Acts also carries a s 131A for an objection to a court’s disclosure requirement; the Commonwealth Act’s s 131A is a different provision, reaching Division 1C only.5

Identify the proceeding as well as the court. Whether the Commonwealth Act applies at all is governed by its s 4: s 4(1) applies it to all proceedings in a federal court, s 4(2) qualifies its operation in sentencing, and s 4(5) — subject to s 4(5A) — excludes appeals from State, Territory and external-Territory courts, and reviews of a magistrate’s decision, except so far as provisions of the Act apply to proceedings in all Australian courts; s 5 extends the provisions listed in its Table to all proceedings in an Australian court. So “this is a federal court” does not finish the question. Queensland and South Australia have not enacted the uniform scheme for their own courts, and Western Australia has enacted it as the Evidence Act 2025 (WA) but has not brought the substantive Parts into operation — only Part 1 and s 384 are in force, and the substantive evidence provisions commence on 18 September 2027. So in all three, legal professional privilege is governed by those jurisdictions’ own legislation and the common law, which this article does not state.5

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.