Admissions: exceptions, reliability and exclusion

Identify the admission and the evidence of it

An admission is a statement by a party to the case, including a criminal defendant. It must go against that person’s interest in the outcome. It does not need to admit every element of the case.

Not every statement is an admission. You must find the specific part that is adverse, and identify whose interests it affects.

Section 81(1) says the hearsay rule and the opinion rule do not apply to evidence of an admission. Section 81(2) extends this to an earlier related statement made at the time, or shortly before or after. This only works if you need that earlier statement to understand the admission.

Both conditions matter: timing (close to the admission) and necessity (needed for context). An interviewer’s question might supply this context. Unrelated talk during the same interview does not qualify just because of timing.

This exception only removes the hearsay and opinion objections. It does not remove other rules, like relevance or other exclusionary rules. It does not make the whole interview admissible.

Records, authorised statements and unfair use

Section 86 covers oral criminal admissions made to an investigating official, given in response to that official’s question or statement. A document recording this cannot prove what was said unless the defendant confirmed it as accurate by signing, initialling or marking it. Sound and audiovisual recordings, and their transcripts, are not “documents” for this rule. This exception does not remove other admissibility requirements.

Tasmania has an extra rule in s 85A for serious-offence admissions made during official questioning, where the defendant was or should have been a suspect. “Serious offence” has different meanings for adults and those under eighteen. Normally an audiovisual record of the interview is required. If that is not possible, the prosecution may instead prove a reasonable explanation for its absence, rely on a recorded confirmation, or show exceptional circumstances making admission in the interests of justice. Explanations must meet the balance-of-probabilities standard. Section 86 alone does not cover this extra Tasmanian requirement.

Section 87 lets a court treat someone else’s statement as a party’s admission. This applies where that person had authority to speak or act for the party, or where the statement furthered a common purpose (even an unlawful one). The real test is whether this connection is reasonably open to find, not mere association with the party.

Finally, s 90 lets a court exclude prosecution evidence of an admission, or limit its use, in criminal proceedings if admitting it would be unfair to the defendant given the circumstances. This differs from the reliability test in s 85. General exclusionary discretions still apply separately.

Applying this in a problem question

First, find the adverse representation. Note who made it, which witness or document proves it, and which party it is used against.

Next, apply s 81. Then check the extra restrictions on first-hand and third-party material in ss 82–83.

Keep two issues separate. A raised coercion argument falls under s 84. A different question, whether the representation meets the threshold and is reliable, falls under s 85.

Then check s 86, plus any other recording legislation that applies, including Tasmania’s s 85A (noting this is a Tasmanian provision).

If who made the representation is disputed, apply s 87 or s 88. Afterwards, consider s 90 and any general exclusions, each on its own separate conditions.

Finally, state what evidence and uses are allowed. Keep this separate from how much weight it gets, or the final verdict.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →