Admissibility
Step one: relevance
Relevance comes first in any admissibility analysis. Evidence must be capable of rationally affecting how likely a fact in issue is.
If evidence is not relevant, the analysis ends there. No exception, no expertise, and no lack of prejudice can save it.
Section 56 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), and matching laws in other jurisdictions, admits relevant evidence unless another rule says otherwise. It excludes irrelevant evidence completely.
Relevance is necessary, but it is not enough on its own. Even relevant evidence still needs further analysis.
Step two: the exclusionary rules
Once evidence is relevant, it must pass a set of exclusionary rules. These rules block evidence that is unreliable, unfair, or touches a protected interest. Each rule applies unless an exception lets the evidence in.
The hearsay rule excludes past statements used to prove what they assert, unless an exception applies. The opinion rule excludes opinion evidence, favouring facts, except for expert and lay opinion. The tendency and coincidence rules limit evidence about a person’s character or unlikely coincidences, because it risks unfair reasoning about propensity. Privilege protects certain confidential matters from disclosure, regardless of relevance.
Each rule has its own exceptions and its own article in this module. When checking admissibility, you must test the evidence against every rule that could realistically apply. The same piece of evidence can raise more than one issue at once.
Step three: discretionary and mandatory exclusion
Even if evidence is relevant and admissible, courts can still exclude it. This is step three: discretionary and mandatory exclusion.
Under uniform evidence legislation, like the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 135 lets a court refuse evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice, confusion, or wasted time. This is a discretion, not a duty.
Section 137 is stricter in criminal cases. The court must refuse prosecution evidence if its probative value is outweighed by unfair prejudice to the defendant. This matters where a jury might give evidence more weight than it deserves, for example due to emotional impact rather than real relevance to the facts.
Different jurisdictions treat this differently: some call it a discretion, others impose a duty to exclude in set situations.
Improperly or illegally obtained evidence can also be excluded on public policy grounds. Bunning v Cross (1978) established a balancing test, weighing the benefits of admitting evidence against the harm of condoning how it was obtained.
In uniform Evidence Act jurisdictions, this common law discretion no longer applies directly. Kadir v The Queen (2020) explains that s 138 modified the Bunning approach. Under s 138(1), evidence is excluded unless the party seeking to admit it proves admission is more desirable than exclusion. This reverses the old common law onus.
Sometimes a statute itself bans use of an unlawful recording, raising a question of statutory interpretation rather than discretion. Potter (A Pseudonym) v The King [2026] HCA 25 involved a wife’s secret recording of her husband admitting past sexual assaults, used at his trial in South Australia — not a uniform Evidence Act jurisdiction. The case considered the Surveillance Devices Act 2016 (SA), which restricts use of recordings made by a party to a private conversation.
Why the sequence matters
Do not treat admissibility as one test. Two errors follow. One is calling evidence admissible just because it is clearly relevant, without checking the exclusionary rules that keep relevant evidence out.
The other is answering on one exclusionary rule alone. Even if that rule is satisfied, discretionary exclusion is still live.
So work in order, for each item of evidence separately: relevance, then the exclusionary rules the facts genuinely raise, then discretionary and mandatory exclusion.
The jurisdictional dimension
Evidence law is not the same everywhere in Australia. The steps for deciding admissibility can differ depending on which jurisdiction applies.
The uniform evidence law comes from the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) and Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). It applies, with local variations, in the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory.
Queensland and South Australia have not adopted this uniform law. They use their own evidence law instead, closer to the older common law.
Western Australia has passed the uniform law but it is not yet fully operating. Only Part 1 and s 384 of the Evidence Act 2025 (WA) currently apply. The rest commences on 18 September 2027. Until then, the Evidence Act 1906 (WA) and the common law still govern there.
The exclusionary rules (rules that stop certain evidence being used) exist across Australia in some form. But their exact wording, their exceptions, and the language courts use to balance discretionary exclusion differ between the uniform scheme and the three non-uniform states.
Because of this, a good admissibility answer must first identify the governing jurisdiction, before applying the detailed rules.
Applying this in a problem question
Go through each piece of evidence on its own. Do not treat the whole case as one block.
Check relevance first. If the evidence is not relevant, stop there.
Next, work out which exclusionary rules actually apply to the facts. An exclusionary rule is a rule that keeps certain evidence out. Apply each relevant one, and check whether a recognised exception brings the evidence back in.
Even if the evidence passes every exclusionary rule, you still must consider exclusion for unfair prejudice, confusion, or improper conduct in obtaining it. This exclusion may be discretionary (the court has a choice) or mandatory (the court must exclude it).
Finally, say which jurisdiction applies. State whether the uniform evidence law or a non-uniform state’s own scheme governs, since this changes how you apply the earlier steps.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.