Duties to the court

Why the duty is paramount

Courts must be able to trust what lawyers tell them about facts and law. If lawyers could say anything that helped their client, courts could not work fairly, and public trust would suffer. So the duty to the court is not against clients’ interests. It is what makes client representation possible at all. A lawyer is never just the client’s mouthpiece.

This means the duty to the court is not just one factor to weigh against others. Giannarelli v Wraith holds that it sits above the duty to the client and limits it. A lawyer must refuse an instruction that would breach this duty, even if the client insists and even if following it would help the client’s case.

Attwells v Jackson Lalic Lawyers dealt with a different question: advocates’ immunity, a rule protecting lawyers from being sued over certain work. The High Court kept Giannarelli but held that the immunity only applies where out-of-court advice affects how the case is actually resolved by the court. So the immunity does not block a negligence claim over advice that led to a voluntary settlement, just because litigation was underway.

This stayed true even though the settlement was recorded in consent orders. The Court said no judicial power had actually decided the agreement’s terms. It left open whether the result differs for settlements that need judicial power to take effect, such as representative proceedings or cases involving someone under a legal incapacity (a reduced legal capacity to make decisions).

Narrowing the immunity does not automatically prove negligence. What changed was the scope of the immunity, not the paramount duty to the court.

Not misleading the court

A lawyer must never knowingly lie to a court. This covers facts, the law, and the client’s case.

A lawyer must also not let the court be misled by evidence or submissions the lawyer knows are false. If a statement later turns out misleading, the lawyer must correct it as soon as possible, even if this is awkward for the client.

Client or witness dishonesty is treated differently. Under the Uniform Law rules (NSW, Victoria, WA), a solicitor who learns the client or their witness lied about something material must stop acting in the case, unless the client allows the solicitor to tell the court. Without that permission, the solicitor cannot reveal it to the court.

Other jurisdictions have their own versions of this rule, covered elsewhere in the series.

Finally, a lawyer cannot build or present a case around a version of events known to be false.

Not abusing the court’s process

Lawyers must not misuse court processes for improper purposes. This means they cannot bring claims they know are weak, or run cases just to harass or delay the other side.

Serious allegations, like fraud, need a proper factual basis before they’re made.

This duty differs from simply testing if a claim might win. It’s a stricter standard, focused on using the court’s process for its proper purpose.

Candour about the law

Lawyers must be honest with the court about the law, not just the facts. This includes adverse authority: a binding case or law that hurts the client’s case.

Under the Uniform Law conduct rules, a solicitor must tell the court about certain authority. This means binding authority, relevant appellate decisions (if nothing binding exists), and applicable legislation. The duty only applies if the solicitor knows about it and the court has not already been told.

There is an exception. If the opponent withdraws the case or agrees to judgment for the client, the solicitor need not raise it. But this exception does not apply if the proper time to disclose has already passed.

Other persuasive authority (not binding or appellate) is not covered by this duty. A solicitor may still choose to disclose it without breaching any duty to the client.

Lawyers can still argue an authority doesn’t apply, should be distinguished, or shouldn’t be followed. What they cannot do is hide authority the rules require them to disclose.

This duty can work against the client’s immediate interests. That is why it reflects the paramount duty to the court, not just general good practice.

Sources of the duty

The duty to the court comes from the common law. It exists because lawyers are officers of the court.

This duty now also appears in professional conduct rules and court rules across Australia. These rules are not the same in every jurisdiction. Some areas share one framework; others keep their own separate legislation. The underlying principle, though, stays the same everywhere.

In D’Orta-Ekenaike v Victoria Legal Aid (2005) 223 CLR 1, the High Court explained why advocates get immunity from being sued over their court work. Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ said at [45] the real justification is finality: once a dispute is resolved, it should not be reopened except in rare cases. This is about finality, not special privilege for lawyers.

The Court kept the test from Giannarelli. At [86], that test covers work done in court, and also out-of-court work that leads to a decision affecting how the case is run in court.

Attwells later held this test is not met where a lawyer’s work leads to a settlement agreement instead. That is why Attwells could narrow the immunity without affecting the lawyer’s paramount duty to the court.

Applying this in a problem question

First, check if there is a real conflict between the client’s interests and the lawyer’s duty to the court. Not every awkward situation counts as a genuine conflict.

If a real conflict does exist, the duty to the court wins. You should explain why this duty takes priority.

Next, work out what kind of conduct is involved. Ask whether it risks misleading the court, abusing its process, or withholding legal authority that goes against your case.

Then identify what the lawyer must actually do about it. This might mean correcting something said to the court, refusing to press an argument, or disclosing unhelpful authority while still arguing it does not apply.

Finally, remember breaching this duty is serious. It is not just professional embarrassment — it can lead to disciplinary action and can even harm the client’s own case.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.