Duties to clients

Competence and diligence

Lawyers must act competently and diligently for clients. Rule 4.1.3 of the Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules requires legal services to be delivered competently, diligently, and as promptly as reasonably possible.

Competence means having the knowledge and skill a matter needs. It also means knowing your limits, and getting help or declining work that is genuinely beyond your competence.

Diligence means giving timely attention to a matter. Lawyers must avoid letting files languish, meet deadlines, and progress matters without unreasonable delay.

Breaching either duty is more than poor service. It is a breach of professional duty, risking complaints, negligence liability, and disciplinary action.

Following lawful and proper instructions

Lawyers generally must follow a client’s lawful and proper instructions. Clients can decide key things like settling, their stance on main issues, and whether to continue a claim.

But this duty has limits. A lawyer must not follow instructions that require unlawful conduct, or that would breach the lawyer’s duty to the court or other professional obligations.

If a lawyer cannot properly follow an instruction, they should explain why. Simply obeying, or simply refusing without explanation, is not enough.

Keeping the client reasonably informed

Clients need enough information to make informed decisions. Lawyers must keep clients reasonably informed.

This covers the matter’s progress, available options, prospects and risks, and likely costs.

The duty links to costs disclosure rules. It also supports the client’s ability to make their own choices.

Keeping a client in the dark undermines their autonomy. This is true even if the lawyer means well.

Acting in the client’s best interests

Lawyers must act in their client’s best interests. This duty sits behind all the more specific duties.

Acting in a client’s best interests is not the same as doing whatever the client wants. The lawyer must use independent professional judgement and advise honestly, even if the client won’t like it.

The lawyer must not let their own convenience or financial interest get in the way. This means sometimes giving advice the client doesn’t want to hear.

For example, the lawyer might need to say a claim is weak, or that settling is better than going to trial. This is because what a client truly needs can differ from what they initially want.

How these duties relate to the paramount duty

Duties to clients can never excuse a breach of the paramount duty to the court. A client cannot tell a lawyer to mislead the court.

A lawyer cannot defend that kind of breach by saying they were just following instructions. Acting in the client’s best interests is not an excuse either.

Client duties fit inside the space the paramount duty leaves open. They do not compete with it.

So the system makes sense: a lawyer fights hard for the client, but is an officer of the court first.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by working out which client-facing duty applies. It might be competence and diligence, following instructions, keeping the client informed, or acting in their best interests.

Then check if the client’s instruction clashes with the lawyer’s duty to the court. If it does, the lawyer cannot properly follow that instruction.

Remember that what a client wants is not always what is best for them. Be ready to explain why independent professional judgement might suggest a different course.

Ask whether the client had enough information to decide properly. If not, say what information should have been given.

Finally, if a client-facing duty was breached, name the likely result. This could be a complaint, a negligence claim, or a disciplinary outcome, not just a minor slip.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.