Confidentiality and privilege
The duty of confidentiality
The duty of confidentiality is broad. It covers almost all information a lawyer learns through the client relationship.
This applies no matter where the information came from. It could be from the client, a third party, or the lawyer’s own observations.
The information does not need to be sensitive or damaging. The default rule is simple: do not disclose client information, unless an exception applies.
The duty generally continues after the retainer ends. It also survives the client’s death.
Privilege as a narrower rule
Legal professional privilege is a rule of substantive law, not just a rule about evidence. It protects certain confidential communications from being forced into disclosure to a court, regulator, or other party.
The main protection covers lawyer-client communications made for the dominant purpose of giving or getting legal advice, or for actual or contemplated litigation. This dominant purpose test was confirmed in Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation.
The High Court in Daniels Corporation International Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission described privilege as substantive law, not merely evidence law. This means privilege is not limited to court proceedings. Absent a contrary provision, it can also be used to resist investigatory demands for information or documents.
Privilege belongs to the client, not the lawyer. The client can choose to waive it.
Privilege is narrower than confidentiality. Some communications can be confidential without being privileged — for example, routine administrative correspondence, or information unrelated to legal advice. In these cases, an ethical duty not to disclose may still apply, even though privilege would not stop compelled production.
Why the distinction matters in practice
Confidentiality and privilege are different ideas. Keeping them separate matters, because they can lead to different answers.
A lawyer may have to keep information confidential. This means not sharing it with the rest of the world.
Privilege asks a different, narrower question. It asks whether a court could still force that same information to be produced.
Do not assume information is safe from compulsion just because it is confidential. That assumption is not safe.
Exceptions to confidentiality
Confidentiality has limits. A lawyer may disclose if the client gives informed consent, within the scope of that consent.
A lawyer may also disclose to prevent a serious and imminent risk to someone’s life, health or safety.
Legal compulsion is a third exception. If a court order or statute requires disclosure, the lawyer may or must disclose, but generally only to the extent actually required.
These exceptions are narrow. They are not a general licence to disclose whenever convenient or morally appealing. Each rests on a specific, defined justification.
Statute now overlaps with this area. Section 131A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), and its Victorian equivalent, apply the Act’s privilege provisions to disclosure obligations like pre-trial discovery. In Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing Pty Ltd (2013), the High Court confirmed the common law waiver test applies “with equal force” under the statute. Check whether the uniform Evidence Act applies before choosing which test to use.
Privilege alone cannot support an injunction. In Glencore International AG v Commissioner of Taxation [2019], a seven-judge joint judgment held that legal professional privilege is merely an immunity from compulsory disclosure. It did not justify an injunction stopping the Commissioner using privileged documents, even though they had been stolen and spread -- the plaintiffs had not sought relief based on confidentiality.
The Court said that once privileged communications are disclosed, a claimant must turn to equity, where confidentiality is the basis for relief. It treated Expense Reduction as only about documents mistakenly disclosed in discovery, handled through case management powers, not as authority for using privilege to get an injunction. Whether equity would have granted relief for breach of confidentiality was left undecided.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out what the question is really asking. Confidentiality is about whether a lawyer can disclose information at all. Privilege is about whether disclosure can be compelled. These need different analysis.
If the information came from or relates to the client, and arose from the retainer (the lawyer’s engagement by the client), treat it as confidential as a starting point.
Then ask separately if it meets the narrower test for privilege. This turns on the dominant purpose of the communication.
If disclosure has happened or might happen, check it against recognised exceptions. These include consent, serious and imminent risk to safety, or specific legal compulsion. Don’t assume disclosure is fine just because it seems reasonable.
Where compulsion applies, consider whether privilege has been or could be claimed, and who has the right to waive it.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.