Fiduciary obligations
Who is a fiduciary
Some relationships are automatically fiduciary. These include trustee and beneficiary, solicitor and client, agent and principal, company director and company, and partners with each other.
For other relationships, courts look at the facts. Three things matter: did one party undertake to act in the other’s interests, does that party hold power or discretion able to affect the other, and is the other party correspondingly vulnerable or unable to protect themselves.
An ordinary commercial deal is not fiduciary just because one side trusted the other, or because the deal turned out badly. Courts are cautious about adding fiduciary duties onto a contract that already allocates risk between negotiating parties.
Even where a fiduciary relationship exists, its scope may be limited. Someone can be a fiduciary for some purposes but not others, and the duties only cover the matters they undertook to handle.
Proscriptive only: the Australian position
Australian law takes a narrower view of fiduciary duties than some other countries. The key case is Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corp (1984). It warns against treating every relationship of commercial trust as fiduciary.
In Australia, fiduciary duties are proscriptive. This means they forbid certain conduct, rather than requiring positive action. There are two such duties.
The conflict rule says a fiduciary must not let their own interest conflict with their duty, or let two duties conflict, without informed consent. The profit rule says a fiduciary must not gain an unauthorised benefit from their position, without informed consent.
Australian law does not recognise prescriptive fiduciary duties. These would be positive duties to act in the beneficiary’s interests, disclose information, or take care. Canadian law goes further than Australia in imposing such duties; English law sits in between.
This has a practical effect. A claim that a fiduciary was careless, or failed to disclose something, is not a fiduciary claim. It must instead be brought in contract, tort, or under statute, unless it can be reframed as a conflict or unauthorised profit.
Informed consent
Consent can excuse a breach of these rules. But it must be fully informed: the beneficiary must know all material facts, including the fiduciary’s interest. Consent must also be free, not pressured.
The fiduciary must prove that consent was given. Consent can also be set up in advance, through a trust deed, partnership agreement or company constitution.
These rules are strict on purpose. A fiduciary can be liable even without dishonesty. Liability does not depend on the beneficiary suffering loss, or on the deal being a bad one.
Even if a profit could never have gone to the beneficiary, and they lost nothing, the fiduciary must still hand over that profit.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the fiduciary relationship. It may arise from a recognised category or from the specific facts. Then define how far that relationship’s scope extends.
Next, work out which rule applies. This could be the conflict rule, the profit rule, or both together.
Then consider whether the beneficiary gave fully informed consent. Remember the fiduciary carries the onus of proving this consent existed.
Be careful not to treat a mere want of care, or a simple failure to disclose, as a fiduciary breach. These are different problems.
Finally, choose a remedy deliberately. Explain clearly why a proprietary remedy is appropriate here, or why it is not.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.