Planning approvals
The planning scheme
Most Australian planning systems rely on a planning scheme. Different jurisdictions call this a local environmental plan, planning instrument, or similar. Usually a local council prepares or approves it, following state legislation. It governs land use within a defined area.
A planning scheme usually does two things. First, it zones land, for example into residential, commercial, industrial, rural or conservation zones. Each zone identifies uses that are permitted, prohibited, or permitted only with consent.
Second, it sets development standards. These are rules about building height, setbacks, density, and other physical or environmental controls. They apply within a zone or across the whole scheme area.
A planning scheme generally sits under higher-level state planning instruments and legislation. It must usually be consistent with that hierarchy. So local schemes operate within boundaries set by state policy, not as standalone documents.
Each state and territory has its own hierarchy and its own terminology. A concept with a particular label in one jurisdiction may not carry that label elsewhere. It may not exist there at all.
The development application
If a use or development is not simply allowed outright under the zone, the person usually must lodge a development application. This goes to the consent authority. That is often the local council, though some developments go to a state authority instead.
The consent authority checks the application against the planning scheme and any state planning policies. For bigger projects, it also considers any required environmental impact assessment. Neighbours and the community can often be notified and make submissions, especially for development that is not permitted as of right.
The authority can then approve the application, approve it with conditions, or refuse it. Conditions might cover design, environmental mitigation, or staging. Because planning schemes usually give real discretion rather than fixed rules, the authority generally weighs up several, sometimes competing, considerations.
Merits appeal
If a planning decision goes against someone, they can often seek a merits appeal. This usually applies to an applicant who is refused approval, or approved with strict conditions. In some places, an objecting third party may also be able to appeal.
A merits appeal differs from judicial review. Judicial review asks whether the decision-maker made a legal error. A merits appeal body instead steps into the decision-maker’s role and decides the matter fresh, based on the material before it, including possibly new evidence.
This means unsuccessful applicants are often not limited to arguing legal error. They can get a real re-assessment of their proposal’s planning merits.
However, who can appeal, which decision-makers are involved, and what issues can be appealed all vary between jurisdictions. Always check the specific jurisdiction’s legislation to confirm what merits appeal rights apply.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by checking which state or territory’s planning laws apply. Do not assume one jurisdiction’s scheme works the same way in another.
Next, find the zone covering the land. Check whether the proposed use or development is permitted, prohibited, or only allowed with consent under that scheme.
Work out if a development application is needed, who the consent authority is, and what factors the scheme tells them to consider.
If approval conditions are attached, check they genuinely relate to the development itself, not some unrelated purpose.
Finally, see if a merits appeal is open to an unhappy party. Keep this distinct from judicial review, which is about legal error, not the merits of the decision.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.