Ecologically sustainable development

The core components of ESD

Quick Read: ESD usually has four linked ideas in Australian law.

First is the precautionary principle. If there is a threat of serious or irreversible environmental damage, not being fully certain about the science is no excuse to delay action preventing it.

Second is intergenerational and intragenerational equity. This means the current generation should look after resources so the environment stays healthy for future generations. It also means fairness matters within today’s generation, not just between generations.

Third is conserving biological diversity and ecological integrity. Protecting biodiversity should be a core part of decision-making, not just a nice extra.

Fourth is improving how we value, price and create incentives around the environment. Environmental factors should be properly valued and priced, not treated as free.

These four ideas are not a simple checklist. They are considerations that push decisions in a certain direction, balanced against other economic, social and technical factors required by the relevant legislation.

ESD as an interpretive principle, not a free-standing rule

ESD is usually not a rule you can enforce directly. Most laws list ESD as an object of the Act, or something a decision-maker must consider. It is not usually a standard a project must independently meet.

Courts generally say this duty to consider ESD is satisfied by genuine consideration. The decision-maker does not have to choose the most environmentally protective option. ESD acts as an interpretive lens for reading broader statutory discretions.

Practically, this means you usually cannot win just by showing a greener decision was possible. You generally must show ESD was not genuinely considered, or that the decision was legally unreasonable in some other way.

Why this subject is unusually fragmented

Environmental and planning law in Australia is split across different levels of government. You need to understand this split from the start, not halfway through a problem.

Land-use planning is almost entirely handled by states, territories and local councils. Each has its own planning laws and local schemes. There is no single national planning code, so a concept in one state may not apply, or work the same way, elsewhere.

Environmental approval is also mainly state-based. But the Commonwealth adds another layer through the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth), the EPBC Act. This Act requires separate Commonwealth approval for actions likely to significantly affect a matter of national environmental significance, such as World Heritage sites, listed threatened species, and Ramsar wetlands.

Because state and Commonwealth approvals come from different statutes with different triggers, one project can need both. A state approval does not replace a Commonwealth one, and vice versa.

Ecologically sustainable development, ESD, appears in both layers. It features in state and territory planning and environment laws, and in the objects and decision-making provisions of the EPBC Act. The first task in any problem is identifying which layer, or layers, apply.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out which parts of ESD (ecologically sustainable development) actually matter on the facts. This could be precaution, fairness between generations (intergenerational equity), fairness within this generation (intragenerational equity), protecting biodiversity, or valuing environmental factors.

Next, find the exact provision that brings ESD into play. Check whether it sits in an object clause, or whether it is a mandatory consideration the decision-maker must have regard to.

ESD is not a free-standing rule that demands one particular outcome. The real question is whether it was genuinely considered as part of the decision.

Also check separately whether the facts involve state or territory planning and environmental law, the Commonwealth EPBC Act, or both. Never assume that approval under one covers the other.

If a matter of national environmental significance might be affected, flag that Commonwealth EPBC Act approval may be needed. Treat this as a separate step from any state process.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.