Workplace discrimination

Protected attributes in employment

Anti-discrimination laws stop employers treating people worse because of protected attributes. These commonly include sex, race, disability, age, pregnancy, relationship status, sexual orientation, gender identity, and religion.

There are two main types. Direct discrimination means treating someone less favourably because of a protected attribute. Indirect discrimination means applying a neutral-looking rule that actually disadvantages people with that attribute, where the rule is not reasonable.

Purvis v New South Wales (2003) shows how direct discrimination is tested. A student was excluded for violent behaviour connected to his disability. The court said you must compare his treatment with a student who behaved the same way but did not have the disability — not with a student whose circumstances involved no disability at all. Because this comparison was not done, the finding of discrimination could not stand.

Protection generally covers the whole employment relationship. This includes hiring, terms offered, promotion, training, and dismissal, as well as harassment linked to a protected attribute.

Two overlapping avenues

There are two main ways to bring a workplace discrimination claim, and they can overlap.

The first avenue is the general anti-discrimination framework. This means either Commonwealth legislation on a specific attribute (sex, disability, race, age) or the equivalent state or territory statute. A complaint usually goes to a human rights or anti-discrimination body first. If unresolved, it may go to a tribunal or court. Remedies are generally compensation, and sometimes orders stopping the conduct from happening again.

The second avenue is under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), which has its own general protections provisions. These make it unlawful for an employer to take adverse action against an employee because of a protected attribute. This list of attributes partly overlaps with, but is not identical to, those in anti-discrimination statutes.

This prohibition has exceptions (s 351(2)). It does not apply where the action is not unlawful under the anti-discrimination law in that place, where it is based on the inherent requirements of the job, or where a religious institution acts in good faith to avoid injury to its adherents’ religious susceptibilities.

Adverse action includes dismissing an employee, injuring them in their job, disadvantaging them by changing their position, or discriminating between employees. Importantly, general protections are not limited to discrimination. They also protect employees from adverse action taken because they exercised a workplace right (like making a complaint) or engaged in lawful industrial activity.

This creates real overlap. For example, dismissing an employee shortly after they disclose a disability could be framed as disability discrimination under anti-discrimination law. It could also be framed as adverse action for a protected attribute, or for exercising a workplace right (such as requesting a reasonable adjustment) under general protections.

The two claims differ in their elements, procedures and forums. General protections claims (not just dismissal cases) also carry a reverse onus under s 361. If it’s alleged that someone acted for a prohibited reason, this is presumed true, and the employer must prove otherwise.

Choosing between avenues

Choosing between avenues is a practical decision, not just a legal one. An employee should ask which forum is faster, which gives the remedy they want, and whether a lawyer is easy to find.

They should also ask whether the reverse onus under general protections (where the employer must disprove the claim) actually helps on the facts.

Statutes often stop an employee running overlapping claims about the same conduct through more than one process at once. They also stop an employee recovering twice for the same loss.

Under the Fair Work Act, a dismissed person cannot make an application under ss 726-732 about the dismissal if another of those sections already applies. This includes cases where a complaint under another law has been made and has not been withdrawn or failed for lack of jurisdiction (ss 725, 732).

Importantly, this restriction does not end just because the first claim is decided.

Because of this, working out the strongest avenue early matters. A student should not assume every option stays open forever.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by pinpointing the protected attribute or workplace right at stake. Then identify exactly what treatment the person is complaining about.

Next, ask whether general anti-discrimination legislation applies. Check for direct or indirect discrimination, and consider whether any exception might apply.

Separately, consider a general protections claim under the Fair Work Act. This asks whether adverse action was taken because of a protected attribute or because someone exercised a workplace right.

Remember that general protections claims carry a reverse onus. This changes who must prove what, and can make this avenue practically stronger.

Finally, check whether there are procedural limits on running multiple claims for the same conduct. Only after this should you recommend which avenue to pursue.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.