Unfair dismissal

A statutory remedy, not a common law claim

Wrongful dismissal is a common law claim. It arises when an employer breaches the contract, for example by dismissing someone without proper notice or during a fixed term. Damages are usually limited to pay for the notice period or remaining term. The claim asks only whether the contract was followed, not whether the dismissal was fair.

Unfair dismissal is different. It comes from the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and is handled by the Fair Work Commission. It asks whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, using statutory criteria.[^cite:fair-work-act-2009-s385-unfair-dismissal]

An employee can win an unfair dismissal case even if they were given full notice and paid everything owed. They can also lose even if notice was technically short. This is because the two claims protect different interests and use different tests in different tribunals.

An employee may be able to pursue both claims. But practical and procedural limits, including rules against double recovery for the same loss, affect how that works in practice.

Harsh, unjust or unreasonable

The law asks if a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. These are three separate grounds, though they often overlap.

In Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd, the court said a dismissal might be only one of these things, not all three. It could be harsh without being unjust or unreasonable, for example.

A dismissal is unjust if the employee did not actually commit the misconduct alleged. It is unreasonable if the employer’s conclusions could not reasonably be drawn from the evidence it had. It is harsh if it badly affects the employee’s personal or financial situation, or is out of proportion to what they did.

The case also looks at whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal. In Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd, the court said “valid” means sound and defensible. A reason that is capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced is never valid.

Decision-makers also weigh other factors. These include whether the employee was told the reason and given a chance to respond, whether they could have a support person present, and whether the employer unreasonably refused to warn an underperforming employee first.

Fair process is not required on its own. Instead, it is one part of deciding whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable overall.

Eligibility thresholds

Quick Read: Not everyone dismissed can claim unfair dismissal. You must first meet eligibility thresholds.

First, a minimum employment period usually applies before you can apply. This period is longer if your employer is a small business employer.

Second, there is an earnings threshold. Earning above a set high income threshold generally excludes you, unless an award or enterprise agreement covers you.

Third, the dismissal must be a genuine dismissal, meaning the employer ended the job, not a resignation. It must not be a genuine redundancy, or comply with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code.

These figures change over time, so always check current Fair Work Commission guidance. Coverage also depends on whether the employer is in the national system; some Western Australian employers outside it fall under the state scheme instead.

Remedies

If a dismissal is unfair, the main remedy is reinstatement. This means giving the employee back their old job, or a similar one.

Reinstatement often comes with an order to restore lost pay and continuity of service.

Sometimes reinstatement is not appropriate. This is often because the working relationship has broken down beyond repair.

In that case, the Commission may order compensation instead. This is based on the pay the employee likely would have earned if not dismissed, up to a statutory cap.

Compensation does not cover distress, humiliation, or similar non-economic harm.

Applying this in a problem question

First, check the applicant is in the national system and meets eligibility rules. This means checking the minimum employment period, the earnings threshold, and any small business rules.

Next, confirm there was a genuine dismissal at the employer’s initiative. This is not a resignation, and not a genuine redundancy.

Then work through harshness, injustice and unreasonableness as separate ideas. Valid reason and procedural fairness fit inside this analysis, not as a separate test.

Do not confuse this with a common law wrongful dismissal claim. Work out which remedy is actually being sought.

If a remedy is available, explain whether reinstatement is appropriate first. Only then move on to compensation.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.