Double jeopardy

Abuse of process

The pleas only cover narrow situations. Courts also have a wider power to stay proceedings as an abuse of process. A stay means the court stops the case from continuing.

This power covers things the pleas don’t. Examples include a second prosecution on a different charge from the same facts, a prosecution trying to undermine an earlier acquittal, or repeated prosecutions that are oppressive.

This power is discretionary. That means the court is not required to use it, and courts use it only sparingly.

The key question is whether continuing the case would be unjustifiably oppressive to the accused. The court also asks whether continuing would damage public confidence in the administration of justice.

Issue estoppel does not apply

Issue estoppel is a civil law rule. It stops parties relitigating an issue already decided between them.

This rule does not apply in Australian criminal cases. Juries give a general verdict, so no one knows exactly which issues they decided. There is nothing specific for an estoppel to attach to.

So in criminal cases, protection comes from the pleas themselves, and from the abuse of process doctrine (a rule stopping unfair misuse of court proceedings) instead.

Still, outside the statutory retrial provisions mentioned elsewhere, the Crown generally cannot lead evidence claiming an earlier acquittal was wrong. Doing so would improperly challenge that acquittal, which is exactly what the abuse of process doctrine prevents.

The statutory exceptions

Every Australian jurisdiction now allows a retrial after acquittal in some cases. This changes the old common law rule. Usually the offence must be serious.

A retrial can happen if fresh and compelling evidence turns up later. This means new evidence that is highly convincing, not used at the first trial.

A retrial can also happen if the acquittal was tainted. This means it was obtained through perjury, bribery, or interference with justice.

To seek a retrial, an application goes to an appellate court. The Director must consent, and the court must think a retrial serves the interests of justice.

Discharged juries and mistrials

Quick Read: If a trial ends with no verdict, the accused has not been acquitted or convicted. This happens when a jury can’t agree, or the trial is stopped for prejudicial material or a participant’s illness. The accused can be retried.

There’s no set limit on retrials. But if trials keep failing, the accused may apply to stay the case as an abuse of process. Courts look at how serious the offence is, how strong the case is, why earlier trials failed, and how much strain a retrial puts on the accused.

A nolle prosequi (a decision by the prosecution to drop the case) or similar discontinuance also leaves the accused unprotected by the pleas. But if it’s used as a tactic, that may support an abuse of process argument.

The relationship with other proceedings

Double jeopardy pleas only stop criminal proceedings. They do not block other types of action over the same conduct.

Civil proceedings can still go ahead, including a victim’s claim. This is because the parties involved and the standard of proof differ from criminal cases.

Disciplinary or regulatory proceedings by a professional body or regulator are also unaffected.

Confiscation or forfeiture proceedings can proceed too, since these are generally treated as civil, not criminal.

The pleas also don’t stop prosecution for the same conduct in a different jurisdiction. However, most jurisdictions have rules against double punishment when conduct breaches both Commonwealth and state law.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by pinning down exactly what the earlier proceeding decided, and whether it ended in a verdict. Then test the formal pleas: is this the same offence in law and fact, or one that was available on the earlier indictment?

If the pleas fail, move to abuse of process. That is where most modern arguments are run. Do not use issue estoppel; say expressly that it does not apply in criminal proceedings. If the facts involve fresh evidence or a tainted acquittal, consider the statutory retrial exceptions.

On sentencing, Pearce is a strong preference, not a prohibition. In Johnson v The Queen [2004] HCA 15, Gummow, Callinan and Heydon JJ called sentencing each offence and adding the sentences together “the orthodox, but not necessarily immutable, practice”. At [26] they said Pearce does not decree that a judge may never lower each sentence before aggregating them to set time to be served.

Statute can change the form altogether. In The King v McGregor [2026] HCA 3, Gageler CJ, Gleeson and Beech-Jones JJ said that without s 53A of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW), New South Wales judges would have to follow Pearce for multiple offences. Section 53A allows one aggregate sentence for several offences, and was introduced “to ameliorate the perceived difficulties that arose from applying Pearce” ([43]).

The appeal was dismissed on the basis that s 53A also applies when New South Wales courts sentence for Commonwealth offences. Jagot J would have allowed it where an offence carried a mandatory minimum. An aggregate sentence still requires attention to each offence ([43]), so the rule against double punishment is unaffected.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.