Sentencing foundations: purposes and instinctive synthesis
The purposes of sentencing
Courts sentence for several purposes, which often conflict. General deterrence discourages other people from offending, by showing what happens after conviction. Specific deterrence targets this offender, aiming to stop them reoffending.
Denunciation publicly condemns the conduct, separate from any deterrent effect. A sentence can still say conduct is unacceptable, even if deterrence probably will not work in practice.
Rehabilitation looks at why the offender acted this way, aiming to prevent repeat offending. This may favour treatment, supervision, or a non-custodial sentence instead of prison.
Protection of the community means incapacitating the offender, usually through custody. This applies where the offender poses an ongoing risk that other purposes cannot adequately manage.
Just deserts and proportionality require the sentence to match the seriousness of the offence and the offender’s culpability. Punishment should be deserved, not excessive.
These purposes often conflict. A sentence strong enough for general deterrence might be too harsh for minor offending; one focused on rehabilitation might understate the harm caused.
Proportionality acts as a limit across all the other purposes. Whatever mix of purposes a court relies on, the sentence must not exceed what the offending and culpability deserve.
Relevant factors
Courts look at many factors when sentencing. These relate to the offence itself and to the offender personally.
Key factors include how serious the offending was, and any harm to the victim. Courts also consider the offender’s criminal history, or lack of one.
Other factors include a guilty plea and when it was made, genuine remorse, and the offender’s prospects of rehabilitation. Courts also weigh general deterrence (discouraging others) and personal deterrence (discouraging this offender).
No single factor decides the sentence alone. Courts weigh all these factors together.
Instinctive synthesis
Courts do not use a fixed formula to work out a sentence. Markarian v The Queen (2005) 228 CLR 357 says judges should use instinctive synthesis instead.
Instinctive synthesis means the judge weighs all relevant purposes and factors together as a whole. The judge then reaches one sentence that balances them, rather than adding or subtracting fixed amounts for each factor.
This approach exists because sentencing factors affect each other. A mechanical process of picking a starting point and adjusting it step by step does not capture this interaction well.
This does not mean sentencing is unstructured or beyond review. Judges must still give reasons and identify the purposes and factors they treated as significant. Sentences can still be appealed for being manifestly excessive or manifestly inadequate.
Even so, the final step of combining these considerations is a synthesis, not an arithmetic exercise. Consistency between cases comes from a consistent approach, and from guidance like appellate guideline judgments and current sentencing practice — not from a rigid formula applied the same way in every case.
Applying this in a problem question
In a problem question, start by finding which sentencing purposes apply to the facts. Explain why each purpose fits this offender and this offending.
Next, list the aggravating and mitigating factors. Aggravating factors make the sentence more severe; mitigating factors make it less severe. Note where these factors conflict.
Check the sentence against proportionality. This means the sentence must match the seriousness of the offending and the offender’s culpability, not just the purposes a court favours.
Present the final outcome as an instinctive synthesis. This means the court weighs all purposes and factors together, rather than adding separate adjustments mechanically.
Finally, remember that the weight given to each purpose, and which sentencing options exist, depend on the sentencing legislation of the relevant jurisdiction.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.