The stages of a criminal matter

Charge and initial appearance

A charge formally accuses someone of an offence. It brings them into the court system, usually by summons or arrest, then a first court appearance before a magistrate.

At this stage, the court usually also deals with bail. Bail is the decision on whether the accused stays in custody or is released, possibly with conditions, until the matter is resolved.

Courts weigh several factors when deciding bail. These include the risk the accused won’t show up, the risk of more offending or interference with witnesses, and how strong the case looks.

These factors are weighed against the presumption of innocence. This means the accused is still presumed innocent at this early stage.

Summary and indictable offences

Criminal offences are usually either summary or indictable. Summary offences are less serious. A magistrate alone deals with them, usually in a Local or Magistrates Court.

Indictable offences are more serious. In principle, a judge and jury try them. But many can still be dealt with summarily in a lower court, if the prosecution and accused agree and the court consents. This usually happens for less serious indictable offending.

Some offences can go either way, depending on election (a choice about how the matter proceeds). Others are indictable only, meaning they cannot be dealt with summarily.

If a matter proceeds as indictable and isn’t resolved summarily, it usually goes through committal. This happens in the lower court first.

Committal is a filtering step, not a trial. A magistrate, or sometimes a registrar, checks if there’s enough evidence for a reasonable prospect of conviction. They decide whether the matter should go to trial.

Committal does not decide guilt. It’s just a screening stage. The exact process differs between jurisdictions.

Trial

At trial, the prosecution must prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt. This is the criminal standard.

In higher courts, indictable matters are usually heard by a judge and jury. The jury decides the facts. The judge decides the law, and imposes sentence if there is a conviction.

Summary matters are heard by a magistrate alone. The magistrate decides both fact and law.

Trials follow a general structure: arraignment or plea, the prosecution case, any defence case, addresses, and, in jury trials, directions from the judge before the verdict. The exact sequence varies between jurisdictions.

The presumption of innocence and the criminal standard of proof

Every stage of a criminal case follows one key rule. The accused is presumed innocent until proven guilty. The prosecution must prove each element of the offence beyond reasonable doubt.

This comes from Woolmington v Director of Public Prosecutions [1935] AC 462. The case called this presumption the “golden thread” of criminal law.

Beyond reasonable doubt is a much higher standard than the civil standard, the balance of probabilities. This reflects how serious it is for the state to convict and punish someone.

The presumption of innocence is not just a formality. It shapes bail decisions, affects who must prove what when a defence is raised, and shapes the trial itself. It stays in place until the prosecution proves its case.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out which stage the facts are about. Investigation, charge, and trial raise different issues, so do not mix them up.

Next, check if the offence’s classification matters. Is it summary, indictable, or triable either way? Each classification has different practical effects.

If the matter is indictable and going to a higher court, think about committal. Remember committal does not decide guilt.

Throughout your answer, keep the presumption of innocence and the beyond reasonable doubt standard in mind. These matter at every stage, not just at trial.

Finally, remember procedure varies between jurisdictions. Do not state a rule as applying across Australia unless you know which jurisdiction it comes from.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.