The framework of criminal defences

Denial versus true defence

Not every “defence” is a true defence. Sometimes an accused simply denies an element of the offence. They might say they did not act, did not cause the result, or lacked the required fault element. This just tests the prosecution’s burden of proof.

A true defence is different. It accepts the physical and fault elements are proved, but points to something else that excuses or justifies the conduct. Self-defence is an example. The accused admits striking the other person, but argues this was legally justified.

Defences can be justificatory or excusatory. Justificatory defences, like self-defence, treat the conduct as right, or at least permissible. Excusatory defences, like duress, do not say the conduct was right. They say the accused should not be held responsible given the pressure they faced.

This justificatory versus excusatory distinction matters more in theory than in most problem questions. Still, it helps explain why defences are categorised the way they are.

How defences are raised and resolved

An accused raising a defence usually carries an evidential burden. This means they must point to enough evidence to make the defence a real issue.

Once that is done, the legal burden usually shifts to the prosecution. The prosecution must then disprove the defence beyond reasonable doubt.

Mental impairment is a key exception. There, the accused usually must prove the defence themselves, on the balance of probabilities.

How burdens are allocated, and how defences are described, differs between jurisdictions. Code jurisdictions define defences in the Code itself; common-law jurisdictions develop them through courts, later modified by statute. Always check which framework applies before stating a defence’s elements.

The well-known defence categories

Here are the main defence categories you’ll meet.

Self-defence applies where the accused acted because they believed it necessary to protect themselves or someone else. The common law test from Zecevic v Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic) asks whether the accused believed, on reasonable grounds, that their conduct was necessary. Both the belief and whether the grounds were reasonable usually matter. Statutes can set a different test.

Duress applies where the accused was threatened with serious harm unless they committed the offence. The law treats them as having no real choice but to comply. Whether duress is available for the most serious crimes depends on the jurisdiction and the relevant provision.

Necessity applies where the accused broke the law to deal with a sudden emergency, to avoid a greater harm. Common law and statutory versions differ, including how closely the response must match the emergency. Check which version applies before describing its elements. Necessity resembles duress but responds to circumstances generally, not a threat from a person.

Mental impairment applies where a mental health or cognitive impairment meant the accused, for example, didn’t understand their conduct or know it was wrong. Jurisdictions define the qualifying impairments differently. This defence doesn’t produce an ordinary acquittal; it leads to a special verdict and different, care-focused consequences.

In Victoria, statute has replaced the common law test. Section 322N of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) abolishes self-defence at common law. Section 322K sets the statutory test instead: the person believed their conduct was necessary in self-defence, and it was a reasonable response as they perceived the circumstances. Edmunds v The King is the key case to read alongside Zecevic on this change.

Applying this in a problem question

Start with the offence elements. Work out which ones are genuinely disputed, meaning the accused actually denies them.

Then ask separately whether the facts raise a true defence. A true defence accepts the elements but points to a circumstance that excuses or justifies the conduct.

Work out exactly which defence category applies. Note whether it is justificatory (the conduct was right) or excusatory (the conduct is forgiven) in nature.

Check which jurisdiction applies, and whether Code or common law governs the defence. Do this before setting out the defence’s elements.

Deal with the evidential burden first. Only once that threshold is met should you explain who carries the legal burden.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.