Mistake of fact under the Griffith Code: Criminal Code s 24 (WA and Queensland)
What stays shared
Every Australian jurisdiction accepts some version of mistake of fact. This means a person who honestly gets the facts wrong might not be criminally liable for what they did.
The core idea is the same everywhere. If someone has an honest, reasonable belief in facts that would make their conduct innocent, that belief matters.
But this shared idea is not applied the same way everywhere. Jurisdictions differ on where mistake of fact fits within criminal responsibility, and on how far the defence extends.
The Code excuse: Criminal Code s 24
Western Australia and Queensland both have a Criminal Code with a s 24 in the same terms. This section gives an excuse where a person acted under an honest and reasonable, but mistaken, belief in some state of things. The act is then judged as if that believed state of things were true.
Section 24 is a general excuse. It can apply to any offence under the Code, not just strict liability offences. This is wider than the common law version of the defence.
But s 24 can be excluded. The law creating an offence may expressly or impliedly displace it. For example, an offence requiring actual knowledge is not affected by s 24 in the usual way.
Contrast with the common law position
NSW, Victoria, and South Australia have no equivalent to s 24. They rely on the common law instead.
At common law, mistake of fact works differently. It excuses strict liability offences specifically, not criminal law generally. This is the rule from Proudman v Dayman (1941) 67 CLR 536.
So the defence has a narrower reach at common law than under s 24. A student moving the argument between a Code state and a common-law state must adjust its scope. It is not simply the same rule under a different name.
Worked overlay example
Here is a worked example. A person in WA takes a shop item, honestly and reasonably believing it was given to them. They are charged with taking something without the owner’s consent, and want to raise mistake of fact.
First, check which Code applies. Here it is WA’s Criminal Code (or Queensland’s), not a common-law rule.
Next, find the actual offence provision. Check whether it expressly or impliedly excludes s 24.
Then state the s 24 test. The accused must have an honest and reasonable, but mistaken, belief in a state of things. Responsibility is judged as if that believed state of things were true. This mistake might excuse the accused completely, or only reduce what they are responsible for.
Apply this test to the facts as the accused believed them to be, not how they actually turned out.
Finally, check whether the evidence realistically raises an honest and reasonable mistake. If it does, the prosecution must disprove it beyond reasonable doubt. This applies whether or not the accused raises s 24 themselves, unless a statute changes this burden.
Self-check
Before finishing a s 24 answer, check a few things.
First, name the actual Code you mean, Western Australia or Queensland. Do not just say “the Code” as if there is only one.
Second, check whether the specific offence provision rules out s 24. Section 24 might not apply to every offence.
Third, keep s 24’s mistake excuse separate from the common law defence. The common law version only works for strict liability offences; s 24 is different and broader.
Finally, check the current WA or Queensland legislation website for the current wording of s 24. Do not rely on a quoted fragment, since the text may have changed.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.