Credibility and prior inconsistent statements

The credibility rule

Section 102 sets out the credibility rule. It says credibility evidence about a witness is not admissible.

Credibility evidence is evidence that only matters because it affects how believable a witness seems. It is not relevant for any other reason. Evidence can also count as credibility evidence if it is relevant for another purpose, but not admissible for that purpose.

The rule exists to keep trials under control. Without it, parties could question witnesses endlessly about their past. This would create side disputes that do not help resolve the real issues.

Because of the rule, credibility evidence can only come in through an exception. If you are answering a problem question, you must name the specific exception. Simply saying the evidence relates to credit is not enough.

Dual relevance

Some evidence is relevant to both credibility and a fact in issue. This is called dual relevance. Because it is not relevant “only” to credibility, the credibility rule does not apply to it.

This evidence still has to satisfy the ordinary rules, like those on hearsay, opinion and tendency. Once admitted, it can be used for both purposes. A court may still give a limiting direction about how it is used.

A prior inconsistent statement is a good example. Under the uniform Evidence Acts, once admitted, it can be used as evidence that its contents are true, not just to undermine the witness. This works because the hearsay rule does not apply when the witness is available and has been examined about the statement.

This is a real change from the common law. At common law, a prior inconsistent statement only went to credit. It could not be used as proof of what it actually said.

Cross-examination as to credibility

Cross-examination on credibility is allowed only in limited cases. The evidence must be able to substantially affect the court’s assessment of the witness’s credibility (s 103(1)).

Be careful with wording. Section 103 uses “substantially affect,” not “substantial probative value.” That other phrase is the test under ss 97 and 98, for tendency and coincidence evidence. Mixing them up applies the wrong test.

When deciding this, courts look at relevant factors. One is whether the evidence shows the witness knowingly or recklessly made a false statement while bound to tell the truth. Another is how much time has passed since the events in question.

Extra limits apply too. To cross-examine a defendant in a criminal case about credibility, a party needs leave, granted only under narrow statutory conditions.

Cross-examination must also not be improper. This means it must not mislead, unduly annoy, harass, intimidate, offend, oppress, or belittle the witness. Courts must disallow such questions, and extra protections exist for vulnerable witnesses.

Prior inconsistent statements

A prior inconsistent statement is something a witness said before that doesn’t match their evidence now. Section 43 sets out how this works.

The cross-examiner doesn’t have to show the witness the document first, or reveal what it says.

But before any other evidence of the statement can be used, the witness must be told enough details to identify it. The witness must also get a chance to admit or deny saying it.

If the witness denies or won’t admit making the statement, the other side can then prove it using other evidence.

This rule exists for fairness. A witness should get the chance to explain or deny the statement before being contradicted by it.

The finality rule and its exceptions

Usually, if a witness answers a question about their credibility, the cross-examiner must accept that answer. They cannot bring other evidence to contradict it. This stops trials from going on forever.

Section 106 creates exceptions. If the witness denies the substance of the evidence, further evidence can be used to rebut that denial, but only with the court’s leave, unless the situation fits a listed category.

These categories cover a witness who is biased or has a motive to lie, has a prior criminal conviction, has made a prior inconsistent statement, could not have known the things they testified about, or knowingly made a false statement while bound to tell the truth.

For bias, conviction, prior inconsistent statement, and false representation, no leave is needed.

Re-establishing credibility

If someone attacks a witness’s credibility, other evidence can be brought in to fix it back up. This is called re-establishing credibility.

In re-examination, the witness can explain things said in cross-examination. With the court’s leave (permission), other evidence about credibility may also be brought in.

A prior consistent statement is something a witness said before that matches their evidence in court. This kind of statement is usually not allowed in.

But there’s an exception. If someone suggests the witness recently made up their story, or reconstructed it, the prior consistent statement can be used to rebut that suggestion. The court must give leave for this too.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.