Members’ rights
The oppression remedy
Members can’t control management directly, so courts have a broad power to step in. This applies where a company’s affairs are run against the interests of members as a whole, or in a way that is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory to a member. This is called the oppression remedy. It is especially important for minority members who cannot outvote a majority.
The remedy looks at substance and fairness, not just whether directors followed the constitution’s technical rules. It is often used in small, closely held companies where member relationships have broken down.
But courts cannot simply impose their own view of fairness. In Wayde v New South Wales Rugby League Ltd (1985), excluding a club under an express power was not oppressive, even though the effect was harsh, because the decision was honest. The majority noted this power was express; if directors instead act under general management powers, courts may examine the fairness of that course more closely.
Where oppression is proven, courts have wide remedial powers. These include ordering a buyout of a member’s shares, regulating future conduct, or granting other tailored relief.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out what right the member claims. This could be voting, information, or dividend rights. Then check if that right was actually infringed, not just disappointed.
Next, tell the difference between two things. One is a genuine grievance about how the company is run. The other is just dissatisfaction with a director’s decision that was properly theirs to make.
If there seems to be a pattern of unfair treatment, think about the oppression remedy. Ask whether the conduct is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory to the member.
Work out who is responsible for the conduct. It might be the board, a controlling member, or the company itself. This matters because the remedy covers the company’s affairs broadly.
Finally, think about what remedy would actually fix the unfairness. Don’t assume a share buy-out is the only option.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.