Directors’ duties
Good faith and proper purpose
Directors must act in good faith in the company’s best interests. They must also act for a proper purpose. These are two separate rules.
Good faith means asking if the director honestly believed they served the company’s interests.
Proper purpose asks a different question. Even if a director acts honestly, did they use the power for its intended purpose?
For example, directors can issue shares to raise capital. Using that power instead to entrench board control is improper. This is true even if the director honestly believed it helped the company.
Avoiding conflicts of interest
Directors must not misuse their position or information gained from it. They cannot use these to benefit themselves or someone else, or to harm the company.
This duty connects to equitable rules for fiduciaries generally. A fiduciary is someone who must act in another’s best interests. These include the conflict rule and profit rule. Directors are a clear example of fiduciaries.
Statute adds disclosure requirements on top of these equitable rules. Serious breaches can lead to civil penalties, and sometimes criminal consequences.
Statutory duties and equitable fiduciary duties coexist
Statutes don’t replace equity. Directors are still fiduciaries under general law.
This means they owe equitable duties of loyalty, covered in the fiduciary obligations article. The main ones are avoiding conflicts of interest and not profiting from their position without informed consent.
Statutory duties often cover similar ground. They’re usually more detailed and easier to enforce, including through ASIC’s civil penalty powers.
Still, a plaintiff or regulator can plead breach of fiduciary duty in equity too. This can be instead of, or as well as, a statutory breach.
Students need to work comfortably with both frameworks in the same problem.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out which specific duty applies: care and diligence, good faith and proper purpose, conflict avoidance, or insolvent trading. Don’t just say “breach of duty” generally.
For care and diligence problems, check if the business judgment rule might apply before deciding the duty was breached.
For proper purpose problems, keep two questions separate: did the director honestly believe they were right, and what was the power actually meant for?
For insolvent trading, pin down exactly when insolvency started, or should have been obvious. Then check whether a safe-harbour-type defence might apply.
Finally, ask if the same facts also show a breach of equitable fiduciary duty. If so, deal with both the statutory and equitable claims.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.