Capital and insolvency context

Why capital maintenance matters

Limited liability means members aren’t personally liable for company debts. So creditors rely on the company’s capital and assets instead.

If a company could freely give that capital back to members, creditors would lose protection. This could happen secretly, through buy-backs, capital reductions, or hidden distributions.

Capital maintenance is the principle that stops this. It restricts how companies return capital to members.

The old “profits test” for dividends no longer applies. Since 2010, s 254T sets three conditions instead: assets must exceed liabilities by enough to cover the dividend, payment must be fair and reasonable to shareholders, and it must not materially prejudice the company’s ability to pay creditors.

Saying dividends can only be paid “out of profits” states the repealed rule, not the current law.

Capital reductions, share buy-backs, and financial assistance for buying the company’s own shares are all regulated. Statutory conditions protect creditors, and sometimes other members, in each case.

Companies can still pay dividends and return value to members. But this must happen through valid, regulated processes — not unrestricted management choice — because it draws on funds creditors depend on.

Two concepts of insolvency

Insolvency can be understood in two different ways under Australian law.

Balance-sheet insolvency compares a company’s assets and liabilities at one point in time. A company can be balance-sheet insolvent but still pay its bills on time, if it has enough short-term cash despite holding illiquid assets.

Cash-flow insolvency asks whether a company can pay its debts as they fall due. This comes from Sandell v Porter (1966) 115 CLR 666, and it is the test actually used in the Corporations Act (s 95A).

This test looks forward, not just at the accounts. A company can look “solvent” on paper but still be unable to pay a debt because it cannot quickly turn assets into cash. In that situation, the company is legally insolvent.

This matters for the directors’ duty not to trade while insolvent. Directors must ask the cash-flow question, not just whether assets exceed liabilities on paper.

Formal insolvency processes, in outline

When a company is, or is likely to become, insolvent, Australian law offers formal processes. Two matter here conceptually.

Voluntary administration aims to rescue the company. An independent administrator takes control briefly, investigates, then recommends a deed of company arrangement (letting the company keep trading in some form), winding up, or returning control to directors. The goal is to save the company or business, or else get creditors a better return than immediate winding up.

Liquidation is different — it ends the company. A liquidator sells the company’s assets, pays creditors in a set statutory order, then deregisters the company. It can follow a failed administration, be court-ordered on a creditor’s application, or be started by members while the company is solvent.

Both processes share one idea: once informal resolution of financial trouble is unrealistic, the law replaces director control with an independent, regulated process. This happens because creditors’ interests, not members’, are then most at risk.

The statutory insolvency test has also changed from the old common law version. In Lewis v Doran, Giles JA noted the trial judge’s finding that removing the words “from his own monies” from s 95A eliminated an artificial restriction. Section 95A now asks whether the company can pay its debts as they fall due, judged by commercial reality — the source of funds doesn’t decide the question.

The same change happened in personal insolvency law. In Whitton v Regis Towers Real Estate Pty Ltd (In Administration), Buchanan J (Marshall and Tracey JJ agreeing) observed that the earlier case of Sandell interpreted the old s 95 of the Bankruptcy Act. That “own money” requirement no longer appears in s 5(2) and (3) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), which use wording identical to s 95A.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by working out what kind of problem you have. Is it a capital maintenance issue, where value moves out to members? Or is it an insolvency issue, where the company cannot meet its obligations? These raise different rules, even though both exist to protect creditors.

If insolvency is the issue, use the cash-flow test. This asks whether the company can pay its debts as they fall due. Don’t rely only on comparing assets and liabilities on a balance sheet.

Timing matters. Work out when insolvency arose, or when it should reasonably have been obvious. Anything that happens afterward is judged against that starting point.

If a formal insolvency process is relevant, decide whether the facts suggest rescue, through voluntary administration, or a terminal outcome, through liquidation. Briefly explain your reasoning.

Finally, remember who these rules protect: creditors, not members. Keep that purpose in mind throughout your answer.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.