Unconscionable conduct
The equitable doctrine
Unconscionable conduct has three elements. First, the weaker party must have a special disadvantage affecting their ability to judge their own interests. This is more than ordinary bargaining inequality — it includes things like illness, age, illiteracy, or lack of needed explanation.
Second, the stronger party must know of that disadvantage, either actually or constructively (meaning they ought to have known, even without actual knowledge).
Third, the stronger party must unconscientiously exploit that disadvantage to get the deal. If all three are shown, the stronger party then bears the burden of proving the transaction was fair, just and reasonable.
Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447[^cite:amadio-special-disadvantage] shows this working. Elderly parents who didn’t speak English well signed a guarantee without understanding it. The guarantee was set aside because the bank knew, or should have known, of their disadvantage, and did nothing to see they got independent advice.
ACCC v CG Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd (2003) 214 CLR 51[^cite:accc-v-berbatis-hard-bargaining-not-unconscionable] shows the limit. Lessees gave up an unrelated legal claim to get their lease renewed. Being in a weak bargaining position wasn’t enough — this was not a special disadvantage the lessor unconscientiously exploited.
The statutory prohibitions
Australian law also bans unconscionable conduct by statute. This applies in trade or commerce, covering both consumer and business deals.
Section 21 of the Australian Consumer Law is broader than the equitable doctrine. It does not require the same strict elements equity demands.
Courts may consider several factors under s 21. These include bargaining strength, whether conditions were reasonably necessary, whether the weaker party understood the documents, undue influence or pressure, and good faith. This list is not exhaustive.
Because s 21 does not require proof of a special disadvantage, it is usually the stronger claim in trade or commerce cases. Section 20 is different: it adopts the unwritten law, so the equitable doctrine applies there instead.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.