Mistake
Common mistake
Common mistake is when both parties make the same wrong assumption. At common law, this only voids the contract if the mistake makes the subject matter essentially different from what the parties thought. Classic examples are when the subject matter never existed, or already belonged to the buyer.
This is a high bar. A shared mistake about quality, value or profitability generally will not void the contract, even if the consequences are serious.
Whether equity can set aside a contract for common mistake, on terms, is unsettled in Australia. Some authority supports this broader power, and some resists it. Treat this as an open question, not a settled rule.
Unilateral mistake
Unilateral mistake is when one party is wrong about something, and the other party knows or should know this. Just staying quiet about a bad deal is not enough to trigger this doctrine. The mistake usually has to be about an actual term of the contract, and the other side’s knowledge of it is essential.
If these conditions are met, a court may refuse to enforce the contract, or may cancel it entirely. In Taylor v Johnson, a seller was wrong about the price term. The buyer knew this and took advantage of it instead of pointing out the error, so the High Court set the contract aside.
Mistake as to identity happens when someone is tricked about who they are dealing with. Courts ask whether the other person’s identity actually mattered to the deal. This matters most in face-to-face dealings, where the law assumes you mean to deal with the person standing in front of you. These disputes typically involve an innocent seller versus an innocent buyer who bought from a fraudster.
Non est factum is a plea that a signed document isn’t really the signer’s deed. It only applies if the signer, through no fault of their own, couldn’t understand the document’s basic nature. Courts make this very hard to prove, since it undermines everyone’s ability to rely on signatures.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.