Mitigation, reasonable responses and avoided loss

Two meanings of mitigation

In Clark v Macourt [2013] HCA 56, Hayne J drew a distinction. A loss the claimant ought to have avoided is different from a loss the claimant actually did avoid. The first asks whether the claimant acted reasonably. The second looks at what later transactions actually achieved. These two ideas should not be merged into a simple claim that any “replacement” wipes out the damages claim.

For example, if defective goods were meant for immediate use, a reasonable replacement might stop lost trading profits. That can limit the claim for those profits. But it does not mean the defective goods themselves had no cost. You must work out which head of loss was reduced, and by how much, before deducting any benefit.

Calling mitigation a “duty” can be misleading. Mitigation really just limits compensation for loss that reasonably could have been avoided. It is not a separate claim that the injured party owes damages for responding imperfectly. The task is to identify the avoidable part of the loss, not to apply an unexplained discount for imperfect conduct.

What was actually lost in Clark

In Clark, the claimant bought a fertility practice’s assets, including donated sperm warranted to meet certain standards. Much of the stock was unusable. Compliant replacement stock cost far more than the price paid for the business.

The claimant bought replacement sperm and recovered those costs from patients. The Court of Appeal said this wiped out her loss. The High Court majority restored her damages; Gageler J dissented.

Hayne J reasoned that the replacement purchases showed the value of what was missing. Using replacements gave no advantage beyond what proper performance would have given her anyway. Working out net outlay after patient payments answered a different question to the value of the promised performance.

Keane J, joined by Crennan and Bell JJ, valued the promised stock at the date of breach ([109]–[110]). Later events didn’t change that entitlement.

This doesn’t mean later receipts are always irrelevant. Hayne J accepted that a later transaction could sometimes reduce loss (mitigation) or increase it (aggravation). Here, neither happened. The analysis must stay tied to the contractual entitlement, the actual transactions, and the specific loss claimed.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by naming the promised benefit and each separate head of loss. Then state how actual performance compares to promised performance.

Next, separate two different things: an unreasonable failure to avoid loss, and a benefit the claimant actually got after breach. These are not the same issue.

Then identify the reasonable response said to be available. Check its timing, availability, affordability and likely effect. Use evidence, not hindsight, to judge this.

Compare any actual replacement transaction with what the contract promised. Use Clark here, but do not treat ordinary receipts as an automatic deduction from loss.

Finally, state the recoverable loss. Attribute the distinct reasons given in Burns. Separately check causation, remoteness, proof, and any relevant statute.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →