Agreed sums and penalties after breach
Identify the primary stipulation and the additional detriment
In Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2012] HCA 30, the court described a structure that can trigger the penalty doctrine. A primary stipulation is the main promise in a contract. A collateral or accessory stipulation is a secondary clause that adds an extra detriment if the primary promise is broken.
This extra detriment does not have to be a money payment. Transferring or using property can raise the same penalty question.
What the clause is called does not decide its legal character. You must look at how it actually operates. Paying the normal price for a service is different from an extra detriment imposed to force timely performance of another promise.
A contract can also genuinely offer an extra service for an extra price. Whether this is genuine depends on substance, not labels. Calling a default charge a “price” does not automatically make it one.
For example, a supplier might promise Friday delivery, with an extra charge for each late day. First identify the delivery promise, then examine the daily charge separately. By contrast, a customer might buy a truly separate priority-delivery service. Both contracts mention time and money, but that does not make their obligations the same.
Assess the clause at agreement, with evidence
In Paciocco, Kiefel J (French CJ agreeing) assessed the clause as at the time the parties agreed it. She did not treat the actual loss from one default as decisive. The comparison looked at how the clause was expected to work.
Kiefel J’s reasoning also pointed to the bank’s wider financial interests. She noted the expert witnesses had been asked different questions, which affected how useful their evidence was.
This matters for what evidence helps. Evidence about the cost of one reminder letter may not cover a party’s full exposure to default risk. Naming a detailed risk model, on its own, does not prove the charge is proportionate either.
A good answer explains what each piece of evidence measures. It should say whether that evidence relates to an interest protected by timely performance. It should then explain whether this supports or weakens a claim of excessive detriment.
Take a $5,000 daily delay payment for late equipment supply. The $200 cost of a phone call is incomplete if the real interest is lost production. Showing that interest needs evidence about it and about the contract’s context.
Even then, the amount might still be out of all proportion. Adding that extra interest changes the inquiry — it does not decide the outcome.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the jurisdiction, the statutory regime that applies, and the exact payment obligation in the contract. Only then choose a remedy.
Look closely at the main stipulation, the event triggering it, and any extra detriment. Work out whether it is a genuinely additional accommodation, or just security for performance.
Apply Andrews to decide how far the penalty doctrine reaches. You don’t need an actionable breach, and not every default charge is automatically penal.
Identify what interests the parties were protecting when they made the agreement. Compare the detriment imposed against those interests, using Paciocco, and attribute reasoning to its source.
Finally, explain what follows if a clause is found to be a penalty. Note any compensation proved independently, and flag the separate statutory questions still to be answered.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.