Offer and acceptance

What makes something an offer

An offer sets out the terms on which the maker is willing to be bound. It is made with the intention of being bound once the other party accepts.

Two things mark out an offer. It must be complete enough to accept, because missing essential terms leave nothing definite to accept. It must also contemplate being bound without further negotiation.

An invitation to treat is different: it invites offers rather than making one. That distinction decides who is the offeror, and so who can accept and who can withdraw.

Goods displayed in a shop are ordinarily an invitation to treat. The customer offers at the counter and the retailer accepts, so a mispriced shelf item does not by itself bind the shop. Advertisements are usually invitations to treat too, as they are addressed to the world. At auctions, the call for bids is an invitation to treat, each bid is an offer, and the hammer’s fall is acceptance.

An advertisement can still be an offer if it is specific and evidently serious enough to be read as a promise to anyone who performs its terms. That is a unilateral contract: acceptance is by performance, not promise, and acceptance need not be notified. Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256 is the classic example. The promise of £100 to anyone who used the product as directed and still caught influenza was held to be a genuine offer to the world, accepted by performing the stipulated conduct.

Timing was discussed in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v J Hutchinson Pty Ltd [2025] HCA 10. In separate reasons, Edelman J accepted that an offeror can dispense with notification of acceptance, and that this is easily inferred in reward cases. His Honour thought that where communication is waived, acceptance will usually occur when performance begins, not when performance is completed as Bowen LJ thought in Carlill (at [52]-[53]). That is the view of one Justice in separate reasons.

Acceptance

Acceptance means fully agreeing to the offer’s terms, and telling the offeror. Three points matter most in problem questions.

Acceptance must match the offer exactly. A reply adding new terms is a counter-offer, which rejects the original offer and replaces it. The original offer can no longer be accepted. Merely asking about terms is not a counter-offer — it depends on whether the reply is conditional.

Acceptance must be communicated. Silence does not normally count as acceptance, even if the offeror says it will. A person is not bound just by failing to reject.

Acceptance must respond to the offer. Someone who performs the required act without knowing about the offer has not accepted it.

Acceptance usually takes effect when the offeror receives it. This applies to instant methods like phone calls, and generally to electronic communications too.

The postal acceptance rule is a historical exception. If post is the expected method, acceptance happens on posting, not arrival, putting the risk of delay or loss on the offeror. The rule is narrow, can be excluded by the offer’s terms, and does not apply where it would cause an absurd result. Electronic transactions laws in each Australian jurisdiction now deal with timing for electronic acceptance, so these should be checked rather than assumed.

Applying this in a problem question

Work through the facts step by step. Name each party clearly.

Look at each communication in turn. Decide if it is an offer, an invitation to treat, a counter-offer, an inquiry, an acceptance, or a revocation.

Try to pin down the moment of agreement. Sometimes there is no clear agreement at all, and you should say so.

Check that acceptance was actually communicated. If it was posted, consider whether the postal rule applies, and whether it was excluded.

Use the objective test throughout. This means asking what the words and conduct showed, not what a party privately intended.

Remember that formation is just the first step. Even a properly formed agreement generally needs consideration (unless made by deed) and an intention to create legal relations before it becomes a contract. The terms included in the contract may also affect it.

Where the authority sits

These offer and acceptance rules come from case law, not legislation. This is called common law: law made by judges deciding cases, not by Parliament.

When citing a principle, name the case and the court that decided it. High Court decisions bind all Australian courts. Decisions of intermediate appellate courts carry weight but do not bind other jurisdictions.

One exception applies to electronic communications. Their timing is governed by the electronic transactions legislation of the relevant jurisdiction. The common law applies only subject to that legislation.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.