Consideration

What counts as consideration

Consideration must come from the promisee, the person trying to enforce the promise. It is not enough that someone else provided it.

It must also be part of a genuine bargain. In Australian Woollen Mills Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth (1954) 92 CLR 424, producers bought wool after the government announced a subsidy. They could not enforce the subsidy as a contract, because the announcement was never made in exchange for their purchases. Relying on a promise is not the same as giving consideration for it.

Consideration can take different forms. It may be an act you were not otherwise bound to do, or a forbearance, meaning giving up something you were entitled to do or do, including a genuine legal claim. It may also be a promise itself. In a bilateral contract, each side’s promise counts as consideration for the other, which is why an exchange of promises creates a binding contract before either side performs.

The law only asks whether consideration is sufficient, meaning it has some value the law recognises. It does not ask whether it is adequate, meaning fair or proportionate to what was received. Courts do not assess whether the bargain was a good deal, so even a nominal sum can support a promise about something far more valuable.

This approach is deliberate. Parties are treated as the best judges of their own bargains. Unfairness is instead dealt with by other doctrines, such as unconscionability, duress and undue influence.

Sufficiency still has limits. Something with no legal value at all will not count, and nor will a promise so vague or illusory that the promisor has not really committed to anything.

The two recurring problems

Two problems come up again and again in consideration. The first is past consideration: doing something first, then getting a promise to pay for it later. That promise usually isn’t enforceable, because it looks like a thank-you gift, not a bargain.

But if the promisor asked for the act, and both sides expected payment at the time, the later promise can still count. It’s treated as simply fixing the price for a deal that was already a bargain.

The second problem is existing legal duty. Generally, doing something you’re already legally bound to do isn’t consideration for a new promise, since the other person gets nothing extra.

This covers three situations. Performing a public duty you already owe isn’t consideration. Performing a duty owed to someone else can be consideration, because the promisor gains a new, direct right.

The hardest case is a duty already owed to the same promisor. This is the classic part-payment problem: promising to accept less than what’s owed isn’t, by itself, enforceable.

Courts are reluctant to apply this rule too broadly. If the promisor gets a genuine practical benefit from the performance, courts may still find consideration.

Equitable estoppel — where it would be unfair to let someone go back on a promise — now covers much of this ground. In Australia, estoppel works as its own legal doctrine, separate from consideration.

Applying this in a problem question

Working through a problem question, follow five steps.

First, find the promise being enforced. Work out who is trying to enforce it.

Next, ask what that party gave or promised back. Confirm that this consideration actually came from them.

Then check timing. Consideration must be given in exchange for the promise, not already finished beforehand.

Also check if they were already bound to do that act, and to whom. This affects whether it counts as real consideration.

If consideration fails, think about other options. Estoppel or a deed might still make the promise enforceable.

Consideration is only one of three things needed to form an agreement. You also need intention to create legal relations, and terms certain enough to enforce.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.