Certainty and completeness
The court’s disposition
Courts usually try to uphold agreements, especially when parties clearly meant to be bound. This is even stronger where the agreement has already been partly carried out. Judges avoid overly narrow readings that would defeat the parties’ obvious commercial purpose.
Courts do this in a few ways. They first try to interpret a vague term using context and trade practice, before deciding it is meaningless. Sometimes a meaningless clause can be severed (cut out), as long as the rest of the agreement still reflects the deal.
If the parties set up a mechanism to resolve a term, such as a formula or a valuer, courts usually treat the agreement as certain enough. This mechanism can still be used even if the original method does not work. Courts may also imply a missing term, often requiring a reasonable price or standard.
But this approach has limits. In Whitlock v Brew (1968) 118 CLR 445, a bare agreement to agree later terms, with no formula or mechanism to resolve disputes, was too uncertain to enforce. This was true even though the parties clearly meant to be bound by something.
Where agreements fail
Some agreements still fail, even with courts leaning toward enforcement.
If the parties leave out a term the contract cannot work without, and give no way to fix this gap, there is nothing a court can enforce.
A promise can also be illusory. This happens when one party’s performance is left entirely to their own discretion. That party has not really promised anything.
Finally, some language is just too meaningless. If the court cannot construe it sensibly, and cannot sever it either, the agreement fails.
A separate problem is agreements to agree. A promise to negotiate, or to settle a term later, is usually not enforceable. Courts have no standard to judge whether the party actually performed.
But this label does not always settle the matter. Two situations are different.
First, a promise to negotiate in good faith can be enforceable, if it has enough detail for a court to assess. Australian courts are more open to this than people often think.
Second, if the agreement is already complete, but the parties plan to put it into a formal document later, it is binding straight away. Whether a document merely records the deal, or whether signing it is required before any binding deal exists, depends on interpreting the agreement.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.