Unconscionable conduct under the Australian Consumer Law
From equity to statute
Equity’s doctrine of unconscionable dealing helps a party with a special disadvantage. This means a condition that seriously limits someone’s ability to protect their own interests, like illness, age, or lack of experience.
Relief is available where the other party knew, or should have known, of this disadvantage and unfairly took advantage of it. This doctrine is covered separately in the article on unconscionable conduct in equity.
Parliament also created a statutory ban on unconscionable conduct. One reason was that equity’s focus on special disadvantage seemed too narrow.
Some unfair business conduct does not involve personal incapacity at all. For example, a stronger party might exploit unequal bargaining power, apply unfair commercial pressure, or ignore normal standards of fair dealing. The statute was meant to reach these situations too.
The statutory prohibition
The Australian Consumer Law (ACL) bans unconscionable conduct in trade or commerce, using two sections. Section 20 covers conduct that is unconscionable under the unwritten law (that’s law built up by courts, not written in statutes).
Section 21 bans conduct that is unconscionable in all the circumstances, when supplying or acquiring goods or services. This section covers both the supplier and the person supplied, so it applies to business-to-business dealings too, not just consumers.
Courts judge conduct against ordinary community and commercial standards of conscience. They do not ask only whether the weaker party suffered a “special disadvantage” in the strict equitable sense (the older, stricter court-developed test). This makes the statutory test broader and more flexible than the equitable one.
Still, the standard is demanding. Hard bargaining or driving a good deal is not, by itself, unconscionable. In ACCC v CG Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd (2003), a landlord refused to renew a lease unless tenants dropped unrelated litigation. This was not unconscionable, because the tenants’ need to settle wasn’t a special disadvantage the landlord exploited.
The statutory factors
There’s no single test for unconscionable conduct. Instead, courts look at a non-exhaustive list of factors set out in the legislation.
These factors include the relative bargaining strength of the parties. They also include whether the stronger party imposed conditions not reasonably necessary to protect its own interests.
Other factors include whether the weaker party could understand the documents involved. Courts also consider whether undue influence, pressure or unfair tactics were used, and whether the parties acted in good faith.
Courts may also look at whether the conduct matched prior dealings between the parties, or any relevant industry code.
No one factor decides the case. Courts weigh all the factors together, considering the whole context. This makes the inquiry multi-factorial and contextual, not a search for a single defining element.
Contrast with the equitable doctrine
Three key differences matter here. The equitable doctrine needs a special disadvantage: a weakness in one party that the other side knew about. The statutory prohibition has no such requirement, so it can catch wider unfair conduct.
The statutory prohibition also covers business-to-business deals, not just consumer dealings. The equitable doctrine has no such limit to trade or commerce at all.
Finally, the statutory prohibition is part of a regulatory scheme. This means the regulator, not just the disadvantaged party, can enforce it. That changes what remedies are realistically available.
Remedies
Remedies here go further than equity’s usual fix of setting the transaction aside. Courts can grant injunctions (orders stopping conduct), award damages or compensation, and vary or void a contract.
Because a regulator can bring these cases, courts can also impose pecuniary penalties (fines) on companies and individuals involved. Equity’s own doctrine cannot do this, since it only resolves disputes between the parties.
Which section applies matters. Section 20(1) uses the equitable meaning of unconscionable conduct, so cases like Berbatis apply directly to it.
Section 21 is different. Section 21(4) says it is not limited by that case law, and can apply to a system or pattern of conduct, even without one identified victim.
The lesson is to identify which section applies before relying on the case law.
Applying this in a problem question
First, decide whether the facts raise the equitable doctrine, the statutory prohibition, or both. Deal with each separately, rather than mixing them together.
For a statutory claim, check the conduct happened in trade or commerce. If you’re using s 21, also check it was connected to supplying or acquiring goods or services. Then name the right section: s 20, where the unwritten law (the existing equitable cases) applies directly, or s 21.
Next, work through the statutory factors against the facts. These factors are non-exhaustive, meaning the list isn’t complete, so don’t just hunt for one special disadvantage.
For an equitable claim, check for a special disadvantage that can be identified, that the other party knew about, and that they exploited unconscientiously (unfairly, against good conscience).
Finally, work out who can bring the claim — the disadvantaged party or the regulator — and make sure the remedy you suggest matches that claimant.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.