Misleading and deceptive conduct

The general prohibition

The ACL stops people from engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct in trade or commerce. This means the conduct must happen in a business or trading setting. Purely private conduct is not covered, even if it misleads someone.

The conduct does not need to actually mislead anyone. It is enough that the conduct is likely to mislead or deceive. So a claim can succeed without proof that any consumer was actually misled.

The prohibition is not limited to consumer purchases. It covers trade and commerce broadly, including dealings between businesses, negotiations, advertising, and online conduct.

Not a fault-based norm

You don’t need to prove intent to breach this prohibition. It works almost like a strict-liability rule. A person can contravene it even if they did not mean to mislead, were not dishonest, and were not careless.

What matters is the effect, or likely effect, of the conduct. This differs from deceit, which needs proof of a dishonest state of mind. That is partly why this prohibition is used so often: a plaintiff only needs to show the conduct created a false or misleading impression.

A statement can be literally true and still contravene the prohibition. This happens if the overall impression is misleading, for example through selective disclosure or leaving out a needed qualification.

Silence can also be misleading conduct. This applies where the audience would reasonably expect disclosure of something, and none is given.

Identifying the relevant audience

Courts ask who is likely to see the conduct. They picture an ordinary, reasonable member of that group. If the conduct targets a group with special traits or vulnerabilities, the test uses an ordinary member of that narrower group instead.

This standard comes from Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Pty Ltd v Puxu Pty Ltd. The High Court rejected a stricter test based on the most careless possible consumer.

Courts then look at the conduct as a whole, in context, asking whether it misleads that audience. A disclaimer or qualification can sometimes stop conduct being misleading. But a disclaimer does not automatically fix a misleading overall impression, especially if it is far less obvious than the misleading message.

ACCC v TPG Internet Pty Ltd shows this. TPG advertised a $29.99 monthly broadband price prominently, but buried the requirement to also buy a $30 phone service. The High Court held this was misleading, because the dominant message controlled, and the fine print did not cancel it out.

Breadth of application

The prohibition is written broadly, not as a fixed list of banned practices. This means it can apply to conduct far beyond formal advertising.

It can cover pre-contractual representations, negotiations, marketing material, packaging and labelling. It can also cover conduct done online or through intermediaries.

This wide scope is intentional. The provision acts as a general safety net, protecting informed markets, rather than targeting only specific deceptive practices.

Remedies

Courts can order many different remedies for a contravention. This flexible approach fits the rule’s purpose as a broad standard, not a narrow ban.

Remedies include damages for loss caused by the conduct. To get damages, the plaintiff must prove the conduct actually caused their loss.

Other remedies include injunctions, which stop ongoing or future conduct. Courts can also order corrective disclosure or advertising, declarations, and any other order that compensates loss or prevents harm.

This wide range exists because misleading conduct causes different kinds of harm. Harm can range from one consumer’s loss to distortion across an entire market.

Applying this in a problem question

When answering a problem question, first ask whether the conduct happened in trade or commerce. Then work out exactly what representation or overall impression the conduct gave.

Next, define the class or audience affected by the conduct. Assess the conduct objectively from that audience’s viewpoint.

No intent to mislead is needed. Just ask whether the conduct was misleading, deceptive, or merely likely to mislead or deceive.

Consider whether silence, context, or a disclaimer changes the analysis. A disclaimer does not automatically fix the problem.

Finally, identify what remedy is being sought. If damages are claimed, check that the conduct actually caused the loss.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.