Anti-competitive conduct under the Competition and Consumer Act
The purpose of the competition provisions
These rules protect competition itself, not individual competitors from losing fairly. A business can win customers by being cheaper, better or more innovative. This is not unlawful just because rivals lose out.
The law only steps in when conduct threatens to damage the competitive process itself.
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) leads enforcement nationally. It investigates suspected breaches and can bring court proceedings.
People directly affected also have some private rights to take action themselves, though these are more limited.
Cartel conduct
Cartel conduct happens when competitors agree to fix prices, limit output, carve up markets or customers, or rig bids.
The law treats this as close to a per se prohibition. That means a plain, almost automatic ban: there is usually no need to separately prove the arrangement actually or likely lessened competition.
The conduct itself is seen as harmful enough. Competitors agreeing not to compete, instead of competing properly, is treated as the problem.
There are limited exceptions, and processes exist for competitors to seek clearance first. The most serious cartel conduct can also be a crime, not just a civil breach.
Misuse of market power
Misuse of market power works differently. It targets a firm with substantial market power whose conduct has, or is likely to have, the purpose or effect of substantially lessening competition.
In Queensland Wire Industries Pty Ltd v Broken Hill Pty Co Ltd, a dominant steel manufacturer refused to supply a competitor. The High Court found this misused its market power, because a firm without that power could not have refused supply the same way.
Under the former provision, Melway Publishing Pty Ltd v Robert Hicks Pty Ltd held conduct “materially facilitated” by market power could be enough. The Court said the comparison was not with a theoretical model of perfect competition (Kirby J dissented).
This is not a per se rule like cartel conduct. A claim needs proof of both substantial market power and the anti-competitive purpose or effect. Simply holding power, or competing aggressively, is not unlawful — only misusing that power to substantially lessen competition is.
Per se versus effects-based prohibitions
There are two ways these prohibitions get assessed.
Cartel conduct is a per se prohibition. This means the conduct itself is enough to breach the law. Courts do not need to separately check whether it actually harmed competition.
Other prohibitions are effects-based. These cover misuse of market power, anti-competitive mergers, and arrangements that are not cartel conduct.
For these, you must prove the conduct has, or is likely to have, the effect of substantially lessening competition in a defined market. Under ss 45 and 46, proving purpose is enough too.
This effects-based test is fact-intensive and economic. It is not a simple checklist you tick off.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out what kind of conduct this is. It could be an agreement between competitors, which may be cartel conduct. It could be one powerful firm acting alone, which may be misuse of market power. Or it could be a proposed acquisition, which may be an anti-competitive merger.
If it looks like cartel conduct, check it fits a prohibited category: price fixing, output restriction, market or customer allocation, or bid rigging.
If it looks like misuse of market power, first show the firm has substantial market power. Then look at the purpose or likely effect of its conduct on competition.
For a merger, first check whether it must be notified to the ACCC. This applies to acquisitions from 1 January 2026, within a set threshold or class, unless excluded or waived. Check whether notification actually happened. Then define the relevant market and assess the likely effect on competition there.
Throughout, keep genuine, lawful competition separate from conduct harming the competitive process itself.
Finally, identify the likely remedy, and who can seek it — the regulator, or a party that suffered loss.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.