Consumer guarantees under the Australian Consumer Law
The Australian Consumer Law as a national scheme
The ACL sits inside the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), but it is not just one Commonwealth law. It works through an “application of laws” scheme.
The Commonwealth Act applies the ACL directly to corporations and conduct with a Commonwealth connection. Each state and territory also passes its own law applying the same ACL text, sometimes with modifications, to reach conduct the Commonwealth alone could not cover.
In practice, you can usually treat the ACL as one law applying the same way nationally. But always check the local applying law for any modifications in that jurisdiction.
This differs from a “referral of powers,” used for the Corporations Act. There, the states handed their legislative power to the Commonwealth, letting one Commonwealth law apply everywhere. The ACL instead relies on separate but matching state, territory and Commonwealth laws.
The ACCC is the main national regulator enforcing the ACL. State and territory consumer affairs regulators, and private individuals through their own rights of action, also enforce it.
What the guarantees cover
Goods must meet several guarantees. They must be of acceptable quality — safe, durable and free from defects, judged by what a reasonable consumer would accept[^cite:cth-acl-consumer-guarantees]. They must also be fit for any purpose the consumer disclosed, and must match their description or a sample. The supplier must also have the right to sell the goods and give undisturbed possession.
Services carry a separate set of guarantees. They must be provided with due care and skill, and be reasonably fit for any purpose the consumer made known. If no time is fixed, they must be finished within a reasonable time.
Contract terms and the guarantees
Suppliers generally cannot use a contract term to exclude, restrict or modify the consumer guarantees. A term that tries to do this is void, whether it targets the guarantees themselves, a right they give, or liability for breaching one.
This rule exists because consumers often sign standard-form contracts they did not negotiate or read. Suppliers also usually know more than consumers about a product’s quality. Letting suppliers contract out of the guarantees would undo the law’s protection.
There is a limited exception in s 64A. For goods or services not ordinarily bought for personal or household use, a term limiting the supplier’s liability (to repair, replacement, or the cost of these) is not automatically void. But this exception does not apply to the guarantees in ss 51 to 53, and it fails if the buyer shows relying on the term would be unfair or unreasonable, considering things like unequal bargaining power. The companion article on acceptable quality and remedies explains this further.
The Commonwealth Act creates a second exception, in s 139A. A term in a contract for recreational services is not void under s 64 just because it limits the guarantees, provided it only limits liability for death, personal injury, or similar harm. This exception does not cover significant injury caused by the supplier’s reckless conduct.
State and Territory laws applying the ACL may have their own additional rules, so these should also be checked.
Remedies
The remedy depends on two things: can the failure be fixed, and is it a major failure (a serious failure, not a minor one).
For goods, a failure is major if a reasonable consumer, knowing the full truth, would not have bought them. It is also major if the goods differ significantly from their description, sample or demo model. It is also major if the goods are substantially unfit for their normal use and this cannot be fixed easily or in reasonable time. Services have similar tests for a major failure.
If the failure is major, the consumer can reject the goods and get a refund or replacement. Alternatively, they can claim compensation for the drop in value below what they paid. Rejecting goods is still limited by the rules in s 262.
If the failure is not major, the supplier generally gets to choose how to fix it. This usually means repair, replacement or resupply, done within a reasonable time.
But if a non-major failure actually cannot be fixed, the consumer gets the same remedies as for a major failure.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by checking the acquirer is a consumer under s 3 of the ACL. This section defines who counts as a consumer.
Next, work out if the deal involves goods, services, or both. Then look at which specific guarantees might apply to those facts.
Check s 64, which stops contract terms from excluding, restricting or modifying a guarantee. If the supply is not of a household kind, also test every condition in s 64A. Look for other exceptions too, like s 139A for recreational services.
Decide whether any failure is major or not major. This affects which remedy is available.
Finally, keep this guarantees analysis separate. Do not mix it with any misleading conduct or unconscionable conduct claim arising from the same facts.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.