Consent to medical and dental treatment in New South Wales
The person responsible hierarchy
Section 33A(4) sets out who counts as a “person responsible” in New South Wales. This hierarchy applies to anyone who is not a child, and not a person in the care of the Secretary.
First comes a guardian, but only if the guardian’s appointment actually allows them to consent to medical or dental treatment. If the appointment says nothing about treatment, the guardian does not get first place.
Next is a spouse, but only where the relationship is close and continuing, and the spouse is not themselves under guardianship. After that comes a person who has the care of the person. Last is a close friend or relative. The Act has its own definitions for “has the care” and “close friend or relative”.
Section 33A(5) explains how you move down this list. This can happen in two ways. Either the person responsible declines in writing to act, or a qualified expert certifies in writing that they cannot carry out the role.
Both pathways require something in writing. An informal or verbal refusal is not enough to move to the next person in the hierarchy.
Treatment without consent
Section 37 of the NSW Act allows treatment without consent in two separate situations.
Under s 37(1), a doctor or dentist may treat a patient urgently if needed to save life, prevent serious damage to health, or stop significant pain or distress. That third reason doesn’t apply to special treatment.
Under s 37(2), minor treatment may also proceed without consent. This applies if there’s no person responsible, or that person can’t be contacted, or won’t or can’t decide.
But s 37(3) adds a condition easy to overlook. The practitioner must certify in writing, in the patient’s clinical record, that the treatment is necessary, is the best option for the patient’s health and wellbeing, and that the patient doesn’t object.
So if the patient objects, minor treatment cannot proceed this way, even if no person responsible exists.
Overriding an objection
This section is about New South Wales law. A patient’s objection cannot simply be overridden just because a “person responsible” consents. But s 46(4) says an objection must be disregarded if the patient barely understands the treatment, and it causes no distress, or only mild, short-lived distress.
Section 46A lets the Tribunal give a guardian authority to override a patient’s objection, for major or minor treatment. This power has three limits.
First, the Tribunal can only grant it if the guardian requests or agrees, and only if satisfied the patient’s objection stems from not understanding the treatment’s nature or purpose (s 46A(2)).
Second, the Tribunal may attach conditions or directions, and can revoke the authority anytime (s 46A(3)).
Third, the guardian can only use this authority if satisfied the treatment is “manifestly” in the patient’s best interests (s 46A(4)). “Manifestly” sets a higher bar than an ordinary best-interests test, so apply it more strictly.
How this differs from South Australia
NSW and South Australia work differently, not just in wording.
NSW uses a statutory hierarchy. If a patient cannot consent, the law picks a substitute decision-maker from a ranked list of relationships.
South Australia’s approach is different. Under its Advance Care Directives Act 2013 (SA), a person appoints their own substitute decision-maker while still competent. Also, only refusals of health care are binding under that Act, not other decisions.
Because the two systems work differently, a student must check which jurisdiction applies. Do not assume the NSW model applies elsewhere.
Applying this in a problem question
This is a New South Wales problem question. Start by working down the s 33A(4) hierarchy in order. Check whether the guardian’s appointment actually includes the power to consent to treatment.
Only move to the next person on the list if there is a written declinature, or a written certificate under s 33A(5).
Before asking about consent at all, check whether the urgency ground in s 37(1) applies. Also check that this ground is available for the specific kind of treatment involved.
For the minor-treatment route under s 37(2), apply the certification requirement in s 37(3). This includes checking that the patient does not object.
Next, test the request against every element of s 40(2). Also consider the patient’s views, as required by s 40(3)(a).
If the patient objects, apply s 46 first, including s 46(4)’s rule for when an objection can be disregarded. If the objection still stands and a guardian wants to override it, move to s 46A and apply its “manifestly in the best interests” threshold.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.