Compulsory acquisition

The constitutional guarantee

Section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution lets the Commonwealth make laws to acquire property, but only on just terms. This power works two ways: it lets the Commonwealth acquire property, and it limits other Commonwealth powers too. Any law that acquires property must offer just terms, even if another power would otherwise support it.

This guarantee only binds the Commonwealth. States have no equivalent rule, so a state parliament can set its own terms for acquiring property. In practice, state laws usually provide compensation anyway. Territories were once doubtful, but now the guarantee is accepted as applying there too.

Three ideas matter most. Property is read widely, covering land, choses in action (rights you can enforce by legal action, not by holding something physically), proprietary statutory licences, and intellectual property.

Acquisition means someone else, like the Commonwealth, must gain an identifiable benefit from the property. Simply cancelling or restricting rights, without anyone else gaining that benefit, does not count as acquisition. This distinction decides most disputes.

Just terms means fair treatment, not necessarily full market value every time. In practice, though, fair terms and market value usually end up being the same.

Some laws fall outside this guarantee entirely. These include tax laws, forfeiture of property used in crime, and rules adjusting competing claims where the rights involved were always open to change.

Heads of compensation

In New South Wales, s 55 of the Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 lists what counts as compensation when land is compulsorily acquired.

Market value is assessed at the date of acquisition. It assumes a willing but not anxious seller and buyer. Any change in value caused by the acquisition proposal itself is disregarded, under the Pointe Gourde principle, now mostly set out in statute.

Special value covers extra worth to the owner that an ordinary buyer would not pay for. Severance applies when only part of the land is taken and the remaining land loses value because of that.

Injurious affection is a drop in value of retained land caused by how the acquired land will be used. Disturbance covers actual costs of being displaced, such as legal and valuation fees, stamp duty on a replacement property, relocation expenses, and business relocation losses.

Solatium is a capped statutory sum for the personal hardship of being forced to leave a main residence. Any increase in value of the owner’s other land caused by the acquisition is set off against the compensation.

Interest generally runs from the date of vesting until payment is made.

Owner-initiated acquisition on hardship

Sometimes land is designated for future public use, like a road or school. This means a planning instrument has reserved the land for that purpose. The owner cannot develop it and may struggle to sell, sometimes for years.

Most jurisdictions let such an owner force early acquisition on the ground of hardship. This generally applies where the owner has pressing personal, domestic or financial reasons to sell, and cannot get market value because of the designation.

Compensation follows ordinary principles. This includes disregarding any drop in value caused by the designation itself, since that drop is the reason for the hardship claim.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by naming who is acquiring the property. Section 51(xxxi) only applies if it is the Commonwealth doing the acquiring.

Next, check if there is really an acquisition, meaning someone gains a benefit. This differs from mere extinguishment or regulation, which do not count.

If the acquisition is statutory, check the process step by step. Make sure each required step actually happened.

Work out the exact date of acquisition. This matters because market value is measured at that date.

Before valuing the property, disregard any change in value caused by the scheme itself.

Finally, consider each head of compensation on its own. Do not merge disturbance costs into the market value figure.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.