Complicity and accessorial liability
Accessorial liability: aiding, abetting, counselling, procuring
An accessory helps or encourages the main offender. They must know the key facts of the offence. They must mean their conduct to help or encourage it.
Just being present is not enough. Even if the person approves, that alone does not make them liable. They must actually encourage the offence, or have a duty to step in.
The accessory does not need to know the conduct is a crime. But they must know what the principal offender is actually going to do.
Accessorial liability depends on the main offence happening. The principal does not need to be convicted. They might be acquitted for reasons that only apply to them personally.
Joint criminal enterprise
A joint criminal enterprise is when two or more people agree to commit an offence. If the offence happens while that agreement still stands, each person is liable as a principal.
The agreement does not need to be express. It does not need to be planned ahead. It can be inferred from conduct, and can even form on the spot.
This differs from accessorial liability. In a joint criminal enterprise, each participant is liable as a principal, not as a derivative party. Their liability does not depend on proving they personally assisted.
Extended joint criminal enterprise
Extended joint criminal enterprise covers an incidental crime, one outside the original agreement. A participant is liable if they foresaw the possibility a co-venturer might commit it, and carried on anyway.
This is controversial, because foresight of a mere possibility is a lower standard than what the principal offender needs. The UK Supreme Court rejected this doctrine. In Miller v The Queen (2016), the High Court kept it as part of Australian law.
Where co-venturers agree to an armed robbery and one kills, this doctrine can make the others liable for the killing.
Mitchell v The King (2023) limits the doctrine. All seven Justices held it cannot combine with a South Australian constructive murder provision (s 12A) to create a new path to a murder conviction.
Three Justices (Gordon, Edelman and Steward JJ), applying Miller, said the participant must foresee every element of the incidental crime. For murder, that means foreseeing that a co-venturer might cause death or really serious injury, intending that result.
Those same three Justices said a participant who only foresaw a lesser crime’s elements can be convicted of that lesser crime instead, for example manslaughter, not the greater one.
Commonwealth offences are statutory
For Commonwealth offences, Part 2.4 of the Criminal Code replaces the common law. This is a statutory scheme, so the old judge-made rules do not apply directly.
Section 11.2 deals with complicity and common purpose (helping or acting together in crime). Section 11.2A covers joint commission, where people commit an offence together. Section 11.3 covers commission by proxy through an innocent agent, meaning using someone who does not know they are helping commit a crime. Section 11.4 covers incitement, which means urging someone to commit an offence.
The fault elements (the mental state needed for guilt) are set out in the Code itself, not borrowed from common law. You must apply the Code’s structure of physical and fault elements. Do not use common law joint criminal enterprise reasoning for a Commonwealth charge.
State Code jurisdictions have their own similar provisions. The common law still applies in the common law states. Always identify which source applies before applying any legal test.
Withdrawal
A participant can sometimes avoid liability by withdrawing. But the rules are strict, and get stricter the more involved the person was.
Usually, the person must communicate their withdrawal to the others involved. This must happen before the offence occurs, and it must be clear and unambiguous.
If the person provided help or means for the offence, withdrawal demands more. They must take reasonable steps to undo that help. This might mean warning the victim or contacting police.
Simply changing your mind is not enough. If withdrawal is never communicated, it has no legal effect.
Innocent agents and procuring
Sometimes someone commits a crime using another person who is not criminally responsible. This could be a child too young to be liable, someone tricked by the accused, or someone missing the required fault element. In these cases, the accused is liable as a principal, not an accessory. This is called the doctrine of the innocent agent.
This distinction matters for a reason. Accessorial liability needs a principal offence committed by someone liable. If the person who did the act is not liable at all, there is no principal offence to attach to. Innocent agency solves this problem by making the accused the principal instead.
Accessory after the fact
An accessory after the fact is different from the other forms of complicity. This is someone who knows an offence happened and helps the offender avoid arrest, prosecution or punishment.
It is a separate offence with its own penalty. That penalty is generally lower than the penalty for the main offence, though not always.
The timing matters: the help happens after the offence is finished. So it cannot have contributed to the offence itself.
The prosecution must prove actual knowledge of the offence. Mere suspicion is not enough.
Some jurisdictions exempt spouses and close family members from this liability. This exemption does not apply everywhere.
Sentencing accessories
Accessories do not automatically get a lighter sentence. Courts look at the accessory’s own role and state of mind, not just what the main offender did.
An organiser who stays away from the scene can still be sentenced more severely than the person who actually did the act.
Key factors include how much the accessory contributed, and whether they instigated the crime or just went along with it (acquiesced). Courts also look at how much the accessory foresaw.
An attempt to withdraw that does not meet the legal test for withdrawal is not a full defence. But it can still reduce the sentence as a mitigating factor.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by finding the jurisdiction. Work out if the offence is Commonwealth, Code, or common law. This tells you which legal scheme applies.
Next, work out what the principal offender actually did. Accessorial liability is derivative, meaning it depends on the principal’s conduct.
Then pick the route the facts fit: assistance or encouragement, an agreement between parties, or an incidental crime committed while carrying out an agreement. Apply the specific test for that route.
If extended joint criminal enterprise applies, state the fault element carefully. The accused need only have foreseen the crime as a possibility. Intention is not required.
Finally, address withdrawal if the accused had second thoughts. Check whether the withdrawal was communicated, whether the timing was adequate, and whether any assistance given was undone.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.