Who may complain: standing in health and disability complaints compared
Four models
Queensland has the broadest rule. Section 31 of the Health Ombudsman Act 2013 (Qld) lets any person complain, orally or in writing (s 33). Section 34 requires reasonable assistance if asked. This is the least demanding test, and the assistance duty is unusual.
New South Wales uses a genuine concern test instead of a fixed list. Section 23 of the Community Services (Complaints, Reviews and Monitoring) Act 1993 (NSW) gives standing to anyone genuinely concerned, but s 23(4) excludes someone unjustifiably interfering. So a person not on any list can still complain, if their concern is real.
South Australia, the Northern Territory and Tasmania list who may complain, but keep some discretion. SA’s s 24 (2004 Act) names categories like substitute decision-makers, and lets others complain where it would be unreasonable to expect the consumer to do so personally (s 24(da), (g)). NT’s s 22 (1998 Act) includes a donee of a power of attorney with express or implied authority. Tasmania’s s 22 (1995 Act) gives the Commissioner residual discretion, sets graduated rules for children (s 22A), and opens the door for code of conduct complaints (s 22(k)); it also names a donee of a power of attorney (s 22(d)). So in Tasmania, standing depends on which limb applies.
Western Australia ties standing to the subject of the complaint. Section 19 of the Health and Disability Services (Complaints) Act 1995 (WA) makes eligibility depend on what is being complained about. Section 20(2) allows a representative to be recognised only if the user has died or cannot complain. This is the most technical rule, and the most likely to defeat a complaint that would succeed elsewhere.
Victoria: the destination, not the standing
In Victoria, the key issue is not who can complain. It is where the complaint must go first.
Sections 5 and 6 of the Health Complaints Act 2016 (Vic) set up a two-tier system. Normally, a complaint goes to the health service provider first.
But some routes let a person complain directly to the Commissioner instead. These direct routes are set out in s 5(1)(da), s 5(2)(a) and (c).
So telling a Victorian client to go straight to the Commissioner is usually wrong. It is only right if one of these specific direct routes actually applies.
What may be complained about
Standing asks who can complain. Grounds ask what the complaint is about. These are separate questions, often mixed up.
In the Northern Territory, s 23 bases grounds on unreasonable conduct. The Commissioner must judge reasonableness against the Code. So a Territory complaint must first identify the relevant code.
In Tasmania, s 23(1) lists grounds including failure to exercise due skill and failure to respect privacy or dignity. The privacy or dignity ground matters in aged and disability care. There, complaints often concern treatment, not clinical outcomes.
Comparison
Standing rules for who can complain differ across Australian jurisdictions.
In Queensland, any person may complain, orally or in writing. Help is available on request (ss 31, 33, 34).
In New South Wales, a person needs only a genuine concern. There is no closed list of who qualifies (s 23).
In South Australia, standing follows a list. This list includes cases where it is unreasonable to expect the consumer to complain themselves (s 24).
In the Northern Territory, standing also follows a list. It expressly includes a donee of a power of attorney, meaning someone given authority to act for another (s 22).
In Tasmania, the list again includes a power of attorney donee. There is also residual discretion, and the rules are open for code of conduct complaints (ss 22, 22A).
In Western Australia, standing depends on the ground of complaint. A representative may complain if the user cannot, within a 24-month limit (ss 19, 20(2), 22, 24).
Victoria uses a different approach: a two-tier destination rule, rather than a standing rule (ss 5, 6).
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.