Health and disability services complaints in Western Australia

Standing varies with the ground

Section 19 sets up three levels of standing, each linked to parts of s 25(1), which lists what complaints can be about.

For grounds in s 25(1)(a)–(h), only a user, a recognised representative (under s 20), or a provider covered by s 22 may complain (s 19(1)).

For the ground in s 25(1)(h) only, a carer may also complain (s 19(2)). This carer standing is limited to that one ground. A carer can still rely on other capacities: as any person under s 19(3) for grounds (i), (j) or (k), or as a user or representative if that also applies to them.

For grounds in s 25(1)(i), (j) or (k), any person may complain (s 19(3)). This is fully open standing.

So the Act is narrow for some grounds and broad for others. A student must first identify which paragraph of s 25(1) is alleged, then check if that complainant has standing under it.

The 24-month time limit

Section 24 sets a strict rule. The Director must reject a complaint about an incident over 24 months old. The only exception is if the complainant shows good reason for the delay.

This means complainants bear the burden once the time limit passes. They must actively prove good reason for the delay.

The 24 months starts from the incident itself, not from when the harm was discovered. This matters most where harm only becomes apparent later.

The guiding principles

Section 4(1) sets out guiding principles for health service providers in Western Australia. Health care should be given promptly, with respect for privacy and dignity, and with clear information about services, treatment, effects and costs.

Patients should be able to take part in decisions about their care. They should have informed choice, meaning a genuine, informed decision, to accept or refuse treatment, education or research.

Patients should also get reasonable access to their own records, though some exceptions apply. Personal health information must be protected from disclosure, except for proper purposes.

Section 4(2) makes these principles matter in practice. The Director must consider them when deciding, under s 48(1), whether unreasonable or other conduct has occurred.

The Director must also consider these principles when making decisions under ss 26 and 34. So the principles are not just aspirational; they shape real statutory decisions.

Applying this in a problem question

In a problem question, first work out which paragraph of s 25(1) the complaint falls under. Do this before looking at standing (who is allowed to complain).

Then apply the matching part of s 19. Paragraphs (a)-(h) need someone from a restricted class, (h) also allows a carer, and (i)-(k) allow any person to complain.

If the user themselves cannot make the complaint, check s 20(2). This section lets an unchosen representative complain for them, so do not assume no one can act.

Check s 22 if another provider already knows about the matter.

Check the s 24 time limit, measured from the date of the incident. If more than 24 months have passed, you must also address whether there is good reason for the delay.

If the Director’s decision is being challenged, use s 4(2). This brings the guiding principles into the specified decisions.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.