Health complaints and carers recognition in South Australia
The Commissioner and what the office does
Section 9(1) of the Complaints Act lists the Commissioner’s functions in South Australia. These include preparing and reviewing the Charter of Health and Community Services Rights, and reviewing complaint issues to recommend service improvements.
The Commissioner also reviews causes of complaints and suggests ways to resolve or reduce them. The role covers spotting trends in service delivery, and giving information and advice about the Charter and people’s rights.
The Act also protects the Commissioner’s independence (s 11) and allows for conciliators and mentors to be appointed (s 13). This shows the office focuses on conciliation and systemic improvement, not on deciding cases like a court.
Who may complain
Section 24 of this South Australian Act sets out who can complain to the Commissioner. It covers complaints about a health or community service used by a person, called the consumer.
The consumer can complain themselves under s 24(a). For a child consumer, the child can complain directly, or someone the child appoints if aged 16 or over, or a parent or guardian if under 16.
Other people can also complain on the consumer’s behalf. This includes the donee of a power of attorney (s 24(d)), a substitute decision-maker under an advance care directive (s 24(da)), someone acting under another law or court order (s 24(e)), or a Member of Parliament (s 24(f)).
Paragraphs (d) and (da) matter because they link this Act to South Australia’s wider legal scheme. An enduring power of attorney or an advance care directive, made while the consumer had capacity, can give someone standing to complain later. So if a consumer now lacks capacity, s 24 should still be checked, rather than assuming nobody can complain.
Finally, s 24(g) is a safety valve. If the Commissioner is satisfied it is unreasonable to expect the consumer to complain personally, the Commissioner may approve someone else to act for them. This does not require any formal appointment — it rests on the Commissioner’s own satisfaction.
What the Carers Charter requires
This South Australian law applies to an “applicable organisation”. Section 4 defines this as a public sector agency, or a person or body delivering relevant services under a contract with a public sector agency. A contract of employment does not count. Ministers and chief executives of administrative units are excluded.
Section 6(1) says these organisations must take all practicable measures so their employees and agents understand the Carers Charter. They must also act to reflect the Charter’s principles when providing relevant services. This is a duty to take practicable steps, not a guarantee of full compliance.
Section 6(2) extends this duty internally. Where an organisation’s human resource policies may significantly affect an employee’s caring role, those policies must be developed with due regard to the Charter.
Section 7 requires public sector agencies to report under the scheme.
Applying this in a problem question
For complaint problems, start with s 24. Find which paragraph gives the complainant standing to make the complaint.
If the consumer lacks capacity, check s 24(d) for an enduring power of attorney. Also check s 24(da), which covers an advance care directive substitute decision-maker. Do this before concluding no one can complain.
Treat s 24(g) as a residual option, used when other paragraphs don’t fit. Frame it around what is unreasonable to expect of the consumer themselves.
For a carer question, work through the five reasons listed in s 5(1). Then check the three exclusions in s 5(2).
Ask how the person provides the care: paid, as a volunteer, or as training. This basis is what the exclusions turn on.
For Charter obligations, first confirm the body is an “applicable organisation” under s 4. Only then go on to apply s 6.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.