Health and community services complaints in the Northern Territory
The grounds of complaint
Section 23(1) of the Northern Territory Act sets out five grounds for a complaint against a health or community service provider.
Four grounds depend on unreasonableness. These are: unreasonably not providing a service, acting unreasonably in providing a service, acting unreasonably in the manner of providing it, and unreasonably denying or restricting a user’s access to their own records. The Act treats “providing” a service and the “manner” of providing it as separate grounds, so a complaint should say which one applies.
The second ground is different. It covers a service that was not necessary. This is about over-servicing, not under-servicing, and does not require unreasonableness at all.
The records ground is also unusual. It treats denying someone access to their own records as a service complaint, not a privacy issue.
Reasonableness is measured against the Code
Section 5(1) says the Commissioner must have regard to the Code when deciding if a provider acted reasonably. If the Code isn’t approved yet, the Commissioner instead looks to the charter, or the principles in the Regulations, or both.
This means students can’t read the Act alone. Section 5(1)(d) mentions a “generally accepted standard of service delivery,” but the real detail is in the Code, charter or principles.
So any argument about reasonableness in NT health or community services complaints must point to the Code, or the relevant charter or regulatory principles. Simply citing the Act isn’t enough.
Applying this in a problem question
First work out the complainant’s category under s 22. This decides who can bring the complaint.
If someone relies on a power of attorney, check whether it covers complaining. The authority must expressly or impliedly include that power.
If the user cannot act for themselves, think about the representative limb. Ask what would satisfy the Commissioner here.
Next, identify the s 23(1) ground alleged. Separate unreasonable provision of a service from an unreasonable manner of providing it — these are different grounds.
If the complaint concerns over-servicing, consider the not-necessary ground. This applies where more service was given than needed.
Finally, when assessing reasonableness, cite the Code, or the relevant charter or Regulations. Do not rely on s 5 alone.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.